If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.

Passed Around

Publishers hate the second hand market - but it may be the only thing that's propping up high street games retailers.

More than a few eyebrows are likely to be raised at the enthusiasm with which US retail giant Best Buy appears to be plunging into the UK games retail market, with the company keen to place games at the heart of its offering as it opens its first stores over here. The timing couldn't be more peculiar; after easily a decade of speculation about when America's major chains would finally begin to exploit the opportunities on these shores, Best Buy is turning up to plant its flag after a torrid couple of years which many commentators see as proof of an irreversible decline in high street retail.

It's tough to disagree with that assessment. Specialist retailers in the UK have been squeezed from all sides in recent months. The core gaming audience, more tech-savvy than other market segments, have flocked in increasing number to online stores like Amazon and Play.com. The casual audience attracted by the Wii is more likely to shop at a mainstream retail outlet such as catalogue retailer Argos than to walk into a specialist store. Even the launch of what should have been a pillar of strength for specialist retail last Christmas, in the form of Modern Warfare 2, was a bitter pill, with supermarket chains muscling in and discounting heavily - resulting in queues of gamers forming outside Tesco and Sainsbury supermarkets, rather than outside specialist stores.

To cap it all off, sales of boxed games have levelled off and are even declining in some quarters. Publicly, publishers and retailers alike dismiss this as a symptom of recession; privately, many worry that the recession has masked a more fundamental shift in consumer behaviour, which would mean that the meteoric growth in boxed sales seen over the past two decades will not return when the economy recovers. Instead, gamers' money and, more importantly, their time, is being absorbed by new platforms with new business models - business models which don't feature retail anywhere on the value chain.

In the face of such odds, the UK's own specialist retail behemoth, GAME, has been forced to start closing down stores and has lost its long-serving CEO. In part, the store closures are logical - aggressive acquisitions and expansions have left GAME in the odd position of having multiple stores in many UK town centres. It's still a stark reminder of how things have changed - less than a decade ago, GAME was easily the most powerful company in the UK industry, capable of dictating its own terms to publishers and holding the success or failure of even high-budget titles in its hands.

What, then, possesses Best Buy to throw its lot into this market - a sector where even the market leader is being forced to downsize?

There are two key reasons. The first, of course, is the corporate drive for expansion, driven by the stock market; corporations cannot stay still, but must instead deliver growth on a quarter by quarter, year by year basis. If that means expanding into a market as unappealing as games retail in the UK, then so be it - however illogical that may seem on the surface.

The second reason is revealed fairly clearly by Best Buy's statements this week. It doesn't just want a slice of the UK games market - which, of course, the company would percieve simply as part of a wider home entertainment offering. It also wants a slice of the second hand games market.

If high street retail of games is facing tough times, then the sliver lining - from the point of view of the retailers, at least - is the second hand games business. The pre-owned market is booming, delivering huge turnover - every penny of which is profit. Pre-owned games have become more and more prominent in specialist stores, and even non-specialists are getting in on the act. That's unsurprising; many customers admit to treating pre-owned games as a glorified rental service, which means that the same game can pass through a retailer's shelves many times, making an order of magnitude more profit for the store as a second-hand title than it did when it was sold brand new.

Related topics
Rob Fahey avatar

Rob Fahey

Contributing Editor

Rob Fahey is a former editor of GamesIndustry.biz who spent several years living in Japan and probably still has a mint condition Dreamcast Samba de Amigo set.