Skip to main content

Making Them Pay

Vindicia's Gene Hoffman on finding new business models, adapting to the digital world - and the games industry's curious traditionalism

In an industry filled with companies whose job is to create menacing alien worlds or soaring fantasy narratives, it's understandably hard to get excited about a company whose job is simply to facilitate the flow of money. Yet that flow of money has never been quite so complex. Consumer relationships have never been quite so multi-faceted and so direct. The chain of transactions linking developers to game players has shortened dramatically, and yet the options for forging that chain have multiplied exponentially. It's not entirely uncommon to hear veterans of the industry, a couple of beers worse for wear, bemoan that for all the fresh opportunity offered by today's market, yesterday's was at least a simpler world.

Gene Hoffman is the closest thing you're ever going to find to a veteran of the brave new world of online content distribution - and, more importantly, how that content gets paid for. In 1998, he co-founded eMusic, an early online music service which pioneered ideas about changing the business model for music to match the online world, rather than shoehorning prices and sales models designed for physical products into a world that had already discovered Napster. Today he's CEO and Chairman of Vindicia, a company that provides payment solutions and in-depth advice on business models to a range of different industries - including some of online gaming's giants.

Hoffman recognises the simplicity of yesterday's business models, but gives no impression that he mourns their passing. "In the past world," he explains, "every business model was some version of a hundred thousand, ten thousand, one thousand, five hundred, two fifty, 49.99... Up front. Then 18 to 24 to 36 months later, you'd hope to get either the same transaction again, or 20 per cent of it. So, big software was sold, in a year I'd get a 20 per cent transaction for the service cost. Small software, I'd sell you an office suite for $500 and get you to do the upgrade for $220 in 18 months. Mario Brothers, it'd be $49.99 - or really, to be honest, $260 to buy the console and the game - but now you've got the console and I'll hit you for another $49.99 for another game later. Those are all the business models."

It's boggled us that it's taken gaming as long as it has to go digital.

"But back when we were looking at the Internet's arrival, we knew that anything that could be disseminated would be," he continues. "Once that happens, how you run the business day to day, and how you go to market, has to change radically. Once piracy is ubiquitous - and once the physical comes out of it - the customer sits there going, okay, digital actually makes this more valuable to me because it's easier to use... But at the same time, though, I could just steal it. No matter what, then, you have this downward pricing pressure."

eMusic was a direct reaction to that environment. Selling albums for $8.99 left the company scrabbling to find any profit margin, trapped between the high cost of acquiring customers who rarely stayed for more than one purchase, and the fee demanded by the rights holder. Hoffman's solution was to throw out the traditional model in favour of offering monthly subscription packages that let customers download a set number of songs, DRM-free.

"Suddenly, wow, 43 per cent of people who'd give me their card - which wasn't everybody but it was quite a few - would stay an average of 14 to 20 months. That's a business model. Now I've got dollars to spend to acquire customers. I'm out there spending $20, $30 a customer, because I'm actually getting, what, $260 from each of them? That's a business model."

Since selling eMusic to Universal in 2001, Hoffman has been applying the same kind of logic to an even wider market. "What I realised was that that dynamic was going to cross software, it was going to cross all media," he says. "Print. Magazines. Television, movies, you name it. Everyone is going to have this problem - including gaming. In fact, it's boggled us that it's taken gaming as long as it has to go digital."

Today, Vindicia works with many of the biggest names in the online games business, from core MMOs like Rift, Star Trek Online and Champions Online (and yes, Blizzard is a client too), through to more casual titles - the likes of MindCandy, BinWeevils and so on. Yet gaming is only about 30 per cent of the company's business - the rest is made up of a diverse mix of dating sites, Software as a Service suppliers, and other online media providers. Describing what exactly the company does is a little tricky, in a sense. Its core product is an extremely robust back-end for payment processing, but it's instantly clear when Hoffman starts talking that understanding business models and the evolution of the market are the real bread and butter of the firm.

The reality is that the most successful products are the ones with no single business model. Even if you say you're a subscription MMO, you actually have a virtual currency and a virtual goods model.

"Everyone else would characterise us as a payment structure," he cheerfully admits, "but in reality what we do is marketing, billing and CRM - and more importantly, business models. What we're really doing is enabling digital services - gaming, entertainment, you name it - to go to market and not necessarily worry about how to execute various business models."

Examples and ideas spring up rapid-fire in Hoffman's responses to every question. "The reality - especially in gaming - is that the most successful products are the ones with no single business model. Even if you say you're a subscription MMO, you actually have a virtual currency and a virtual goods model in operation. Fundamentally, what we're doing is giving the game producer, the marketer and the designer all the tools necessary to get away from the cash register." He rattles through examples - an MMO developer who wants to know how to maximise the revenue boost from the switch to freemium. A publisher who needs to mine through complex B-test data to see if dropping the price of a virtual item will give a sales upswing.

"Being able to run that easily, to pull the data all the way back from the billing - that's important, because it goes beyond the simple yes-no answer. For example, if you offer that customer a lower priced virtual currency item, did that actually extend his purchase life? Even though you may not be getting optimal revenue per, you're leaving maybe a pound on the table, is he doing an additional transaction later that you otherwise weren't getting? It's about being able to do that level of analysis, directly in that our tools make it easy to do that, but also in the sense of having us there to train you about how to ask those sorts of questions."

Rob Fahey avatar
Rob Fahey: Rob Fahey is a former editor of who spent several years living in Japan and probably still has a mint condition Dreamcast Samba de Amigo set.
Related topics