Funcom: Steam user reviews should be region gated

With "review bombs" now a common occurrence, CEO Rui Casais believes Steam should follow other stores and ditch "global" user ratings

Funcom CEO Rui Casais believes that Steam's user reviews should be gated by region, to better protect developers from the commercial impact of "review bombs" related to country-specific problems.

Speaking to recently, Casais admitted there are several areas in which Funcom was "not too happy with how the Steam system works," but Valve's global approach to tallying user reviews had caused the company problems with its Early Access hit, Conan Exiles.

On almost every major storefront, Casais said, the visible review score is based on ratings from that user's region. Xbox, PlayStation, iOS, Android; each operates in a similar way, but Steam is different.

"On Steam, the ratings are global," he continued. "For multiplayer games - and I think this is true for all multiplayer games, all games that have servers... Let's say that I'm in New Zealand, and I have a terrible connection to the servers because they are just too far away. I would give the game a thumbs down, because it just doesn't work for me. And that's fair.

"For multiplayer games, which is what Funcom does, I think this is extremely relevant"

"But if I live in Germany, and I'm sitting next to the servers, I'll have a great experience and I'll give the game a thumbs up. [In Germany] I shouldn't be influenced by the negative opinion of the person who happens to be far away from the servers.

"For multiplayer games, which is what Funcom does, I think this is extremely relevant."

It had been particularly relevant in the month preceding our interview, when Conan Exiles had been "review bombed" by Chinese players. According to Casais, the game's "recent" rating from Chinese players on Steam was around 7%, which had a big impact on the score visible to players in other regions.

"In the last 30 days the revenue from Chinese players - the sales that we've made - was around 2% of the total sales. But the number of negative reviews made in the last 30 days, 40% were from China. There is a huge disconnect between the money we get from that territory and the amount of feedback. It makes it extremely difficult to manage.

Casais continued: "In the case of our Chinese review bomb, the problems are exactly because of servers. That shouldn't affect our Western players, because they don't have those specific problems."

Funcom is particularly attuned to the way the technical stability of its games is perceived at this point in time. When the Oslo-based developer rebranded at the end of August, it was in part to break free from negative associations created by unpolished products from its past.

"Funcom games have always been rough diamonds," Casais said at the time. "Fantastic potential, great ideas, innovative gameplay and systems, but they weren't always polished to the utmost shine... It is something that we're taking very seriously, that we want to address. We want to have more games being made and to keep pushing innovation, but quality cannot be sacrificed."

"There are several changes that we believe the Steam system could have, but that would be the first and the easiest"

On Steam, though, the issues players have in one country can have an impact on how a game is viewed in another, where those issues don't necessarily exist. And the impact goes beyond mere perception; Casais was as certain as it is possible to be that "review bombs" undermine commercial performance.

"It absolutely has an impact on sales. There is no doubt about it," he said. "Conan Exiles recent ratings dipped to 'Mostly Negative' for a day or two because of the review bomb, and we saw an immediate impact. I mean, you can never say 100%, right? Correlation doesn't always mean causation, but the correlation is very, very strong there."

With review bombs an increasingly familiar occurrence, Casais believes region gating would have a swift and positive impact on the store. Indeed, Valve's policies can mean "life or death" for a large number of developers, particularly smaller companies that may get the majority of their revenue from Steam.

"They [Valve] have a lot of responsibility, and they feel it; that's why they are very careful and take a careful approach to changes," Casais said. "While I would like them to just fix it quickly, I also respect that they need to take their time to try to understand the impact.

"It is difficult for them. But I wish they would move a tiny bit faster on some of the issues that I don't see how they could make things worse - especially the region gating of reviews.

"There are several changes that we believe the system could have, but that would be the first and the easiest. And it's a standard change - all the other stores already do it."

More stories

Funcom acquires majority stake in The Outsiders

The Norwegian company is also opening a new office in Romania, dedicated to QA

By Marie Dealessandri

Tencent bids to acquire 100% of Funcom

Proposed deal would value the Norwegian studio at around $148 million

By Matthew Handrahan

Latest comments (6)

Andrey Kostyushko Creoteam CEO, CREOTEAM4 years ago
I think that Steam should take to account the reviews from the countries the game is localized to.

If you don't localize the game for China, you won't use servers there, and so, you don't want the Chinese reviewers affected the whole rating. Especially it is important for the thumb downs with the comments "no Chinese localization".

However, there might be a problem with the regions where players understand few languages.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Bjorn Larsson CEO/EP/CD, Legendo Entertainment4 years ago
Steam should offer its users a "regional division preset" via each game's reviews section. On a side-note, our game Flying Tigers: Shadows Over China got (mildly) review-bombed by Chinese (mainland) players in the past couple of weeks for no apparent reason (earlier in the year it was the opposite, mostly review-love from China).
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Hugo Trepanier Senior Game Designer, Ludia4 years ago
I see a problem for smaller indie titles that struggle to reach momentum with a sizable audience. They need all the exposure they can get, and having one global review system helps achieve that.

If you divide that audience into even smaller fragments you are doing these games a disservice because some regions may not even have enough reviews to provide a positive/negative rating to the game.

Perhaps a better approach would be to indicate the country or region of origin for players that submit reviews. This way interested readers could filter out by region optionally, as they already can by language (which in many cases already more or less serves the same purpose).

Edited 2 times. Last edit by Hugo Trepanier on 13th September 2017 5:35pm

3Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Show all comments (6)
Klaus Preisinger Freelance Writing 4 years ago
Fun Fact:
Steam has the option to filter for reviews which are in "your language" and does so by default. That makes reading the German reviews very regional to say the least. Same for Chinese. Only the the rating in the shop is a global aggregate. But once you click on it....
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Or Funcom could have chosen to not offer the game in China until they were ready to support it there, but they chose not to do that but instead take players money. Keep in mind this is a paid game not a F2P one, so players can't just jump in for 5 minutes and bomb you, they actually have to pay you money, bomb you and then ask for a refund.

So I fail to see the problem here. Don't want to suffer this problem? Region lock out out of the territories you're not ready to provide support for.

Edited 1 times. Last edit by Jon Kimmich on 13th September 2017 6:32pm

1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Owen Hughes Digital and Relationship Marketing Manager, Ubisoft4 years ago
With all English language reviews grouped, negative New Zealand reviews can certainly be lost among satisfied Canadian or American opinions. A location/country filter would help distant markets avoid your game if frustrating experiences when servers are located on the other side of the world.

The risk is that dissatisfaction could easily be quarantined from the rest of the userbase, which can lead to smaller, less profitable regions being ignored by publishers. Does the average American customer care if the online experience is shitty in Australia? Probably not, but the Australian customer still want their complaints to be heard and addressed. Hugo's solution, that a reviewer should have a declared country indicated, would be a simple and useful solution.
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply

Sign in to contribute

Need an account? Register now.