Close
Are you sure? Are you sure you want to report this comment? I understand, report it. Cancel

Digital Foundry

Samsung Galaxy Note 2 review

Samsung Galaxy Note 2 review

Sun 16 Dec 2012 10:00am GMT / 5:00am EST / 2:00am PST
HardwareDigital Foundry

Everyone's favourite phone/tablet hybrid gets a makeover. Digital Foundry tackles the biggest Android phone yet

The original Samsung Galaxy Note was a concept that really shouldn't have succeeded; a phone with a finger-stretching 5.3-inch screen by rights should be a laughable spectacle, yet it found a receptive audience and at the time of writing has sold five million units worldwide. Such was its popularity that Samsung has released a successor in double-quick time and true to form has equipped it with an even larger display. We can hear trouser pockets all over the globe groaning with discomfort already.

"The stylus is incredibly accurate, even more so than the pressure-based pens used on the Nintendo 3DS and Wii U"

However, increased screen size isn't the only thing the Galaxy Note 2 brings to the table. It's packing a Exynos 4412 chipset which contains a quad-core 1.6 GHz Cortex-A9 CPU, aided by a roomy 2GB of RAM. There's some fearsome power contained within the imposing frame of this massive mobile, as well as Android 4.1 (also known as Jelly Bean) and a smattering of exclusive Samsung applications which take advantage of the phone's signature S Pen stylus.

There's no escaping it - the Galaxy Note 2, like its forerunner, is gigantic. It straddles the divide between mobile phone and tablet quite awkwardly, never really feeling like it can be classified as either device. The Note 2's immense proportions also make it difficult to cram into all but the most accommodating pockets, and it's more comfortable when riding inside a satchel or handbag. For those who like to travel light, this is likely to present quite an issue.

Samsung's love of glossy plastic remains unchecked and the Galaxy Note 2 is notable for the complete absence of metal surfaces. The shiny trim which runs around the edge of the phone is simply plastic with a faux-metal coating, and the battery cover is a wall of fingerprint-attracting material. Even so, the handset never feels cheap and nasty; it's got a reassuring heft to it, and when the rear cover is snapped into place the device is solid and robust.

Like its predecessor, a fair degree of the Galaxy Note 2's unique functionality revolves around that unique S Pen stylus. It docks in the bottom-right corner of the handset and is utilised in a wide variety of ways - some of which we'll come to later. The new-look S Pen has a flat edge which makes it easier to grip, and a button which allows you to change how the capacitive screen reacts to its touch.

Utilising Electro-Magnetic Resonance (EMR) technology, the stylus is incredibly accurate, even more so than the traditional pressure-based pen you'd encounter on a device like the Nintendo 3DS or the Wii U GamePad. Its most impressive party trick is the fact that it works even when the tip isn't touching the screen - this "floating" state (dubbed "Air View" by Samsung) is used to show additional information about menu selections, similar to rolling your mouse pointer over an image on your PC monitor.

Naturally, whenever you have something which detaches from your handset there's the ever-present danger that you could lose or misplace it - especially when you're on a crowded bus or in a packed bar. Thankfully you can enable a feature which makes the phone emit an audible warning when you walk away without the S Pen docked - whether or not you'll be able to hear this over the din is another matter entirely.

The screen's the star

The 5.5-inch Super AMOLED Plus screen is larger than the one seen on the previous model, but the overall resolution takes a slight tumble from 800x1280 pixels to 720x1280 pixels. The reason for this resolution reduction - which also brings the pixel density down from 285 to 267 ppi - is that the Galaxy Note 2 boasts a 16:9 aspect ratio screen, making it better suited for watching movies.

One of the most obvious benefits of that powerful quad-core hardware is performance. Lag and jerkiness have accompanied Android almost from day one, and it's only now that these unfortunate issues are being put to bed. The Galaxy Note 2 is responsive and smooth, challenging the Nexus 4 for sheer user satisfaction. Application loading is lightning fast, the camera boots up in double-quick time and navigating the web is a real joy - something which is accentuated by that large screen, giving an almost tablet-like experience for web addicts.

Galaxy Nexus (Android 4.1) HTC One X Nexus 4 Galaxy Note 2
Quadrant Standard 2078 4870 4906 5765
AnTuTu Benchmark 4724 11065 10580 13305
Vellamo 1199 1661 1314 2421
GLBenchmark 2.5.1 Egypt HD On-Screen/Device Native Res 8.3FPS 21.7FPS 39FPS 18FPS
GLBenchmark 2.5.1 Egypt HD Off-Screen/1080p 5.4FPS 14FPS 31FPS 17FPS

Most Android devotees will tell you that manufacturer-created skins - which sit atop the core Android operating system and are generally responsible for the fragmented nature of the marketplace - are a thoroughly bad idea, but when they're done well they can make the device in question feel entirely different from its competitors.

That's most certainly the case with the Galaxy Note 2; its custom TouchWiz UI is bursting with unique features and ideas. Some we've already seen on the Galaxy S3, but there are others which tie in directly with the aforementioned S Pen.

"OEM skins are usually frowned upon by Android enthusiasts, but Samsung's TouchWiz UI is bursting with unique features and ideas"

The moment you remove the S Pen from its dock, the phone offers up relevant shortcuts that make use of the stylus, allowing you to swiftly jot down a note without having to trawl through your phone's application drawer to find the relevant program.

Another neat use for the stylus is "cutting" out sections of the screen to send to friends via Bluetooth or email - while this might seem a bit unnecessary when Android has screen capture baked-into the OS, it allows you to embrace your artistic side and create scrapbook-style collages.

Another revelation is the ability to run two applications on the same screen. Pressing the holding the back button opens up a slide-in menu on the left-hand side of the screen; by dragging and dropping the application icons stowed away in this menu you can load up two of your most-used apps and run them in tandem. This only works with certain programs at present, but they cover all the important bases: email, gallery, Twitter and web browsing, to give just a few examples. Another cool feature is the pop-out video player, which allows you to watch a movie in a floating window while performing other tasks.

"The massive 5.5-inch Super AMOLED Plus screen with its 720p resolution is a boon for mobile gaming"

2

That 5.5-inch Super AMOLED Plus screen is the perfect playground for mobile gamers.

The Galaxy Note 2's massive screen is matched by an equally formidable 3100 mAh battery. Some of that additional stamina is naturally required to satisfy the demands of the 5.5-inch display, but even so, the power cell has impressive staying power.

As is usually the case when reviewing a handset, we indulged in some pretty heavy use on the first day of the test - surfing the web, playing games, watching HD videos, that kind of thing - yet the Galaxy Note 2's battery was still goading us for more punishment as the day came to a close. With a more moderate usage pattern you can easily get two days or more out of a single charge - something that, in our personal experience at least, has never been possible for Android power users. Even better, the battery is replaceable, so you can always carry a spare for those long trips.

The original Galaxy Note was a mobile gamer's dream - the massive screen provided the perfect platform for portable entertainment. Given its enhanced specifications, it should come as no shock to discover that the same is true of the Galaxy Note 2; games such as NOVA 3 and Jetpack Joyride look beautiful on the large display and the powerful Exynos 4412 chipset appears well equipped to handle more advanced titles. Performance is impressive overall and the S Pen comes in handy as a surprisingly effective alternative to using your fingers.

Galaxy Note 2: the Digital Foundry verdict

Samsung has taken a fairly traditional upgrade path with the Galaxy Note 2; it's larger and more powerful than its forerunner, with better software and vastly improved interface. However, none of this matters if you found the original Note to be too gargantuan for your Hobbit-like hands and skinny-jean pockets; the phone's dimensions are unquestionably a bone of contention and push this device off the radar of many consumers.

Despite this barrier to acceptance, the track record of the Note proves that a market exists for large-screen handsets such as this one; you only have to look around you when you're next on the tube or bus to see how popular the product has been with the general public. Whether or not this sequel can emulate the stellar sales of its ancestor remain to be seen but we really enjoyed using this device, and once again it illustrates just how far Samsung has come in the past few years.

Thanks to Vodafone for supplying the phone used in this review.

8 Comments

Paul Johnson
Managing Director / Lead code monkey

799 996 1.2
The first time I saw one of these things, an ex-colleague pulled one out in a pub after a tradeshow. I couldn't believe how big it was. If you think it's big, you're underdoing it. :)

I remember when race was on to have an unfeasibly small phone. Now the race is on to be stupidly massive. :)

Posted:A year ago

#1

Bruce Everiss
Marketing Consultant

1,692 594 0.4
All the expert commentators said that the Note would fail. 5+ million units later and Samsung have been proven right. For very many people this is the ideal phone and it will do what other phones can't. So now the commentators either give it grudging respect or damn it with faint praise. They still cannot see that there are horses for courses.

Posted:A year ago

#2
I think the optimal size will be - has to fit pocket, half the size of the ipad

Posted:A year ago

#3

Richard Westmoreland
Game Desginer

138 89 0.6
My other half has just purchased one of these. She thought the screen on iPhones were far too small. As she keeps the phone in her handbag the size isn't really an issue and as she uses it mostly for internet and reading it's ideal for her. This isn't a mass market phone, but it has its niches.

Posted:A year ago

#4

Neil Millstone
Director

32 12 0.4
I've just got one of these, and it's so much more comfortable for reading documents than a smaller screen phone, also, for writing email there's enough room for the portrait keyboard on screen alongside a decent portion of the email you're replying to. Coming from a Blackberry, the text input had to be great, and the on-screen keyboards on smaller phones are just too fiddly. Adding the Swype gesture keyboard and I'm almost as quick as I was on the old Blackberry keyboard.

It goes without saying that Netflix, GTA III, Google Maps etc. all benefit from a high resolution large screen. The battery can't be beaten either, I'm yet to get to the end of the day with much less than 40%, and that's with very heavy use with the power saving features turned off.

It also fits in all my pockets (just) although you always know you have it on you...

Posted:A year ago

#5

Craig Page
Programmer

382 218 0.6
Reviewers like you are the reason the rest of us can't have nice phones!! :)

My 4.7" Nexus 4 fits easily into my pocket, my 5.5" Vita (with buttons extending on the sides) also fits but sticks out a little. If I could use my Vita or a Nexus 7 as a phone I would.

I think the obvious answer for those who want their skinny jeans and big phones too, is to sew on some new pockets on their outside of their jeans.

Posted:A year ago

#6

Lewis Brown
Snr Sourcer/Recruiter

193 52 0.3
I have a sensation XL (4.7" screen) and when my contract comes up for renewl in March I shall likely get one of these. But then I have very long thumbs. Great little reveiw too!

Posted:A year ago

#7
My wife had an original Note and after using it my old S2 started to feel cramped. I got a Note 2 in October it's a fantastic phone!
I don't find it too large...it fits in all my pockets...I think in 2 years all smart phones will have screens of this kind of size.

The stylus integration on the Note 2 is fantastic...the 'air view' features are truely groundbreaking on a phone.

Every person I've demo'd the phone to has decided they want one of these come 'upgrade time'...and that includes many die hard iPhone users.
As stated in a previous post the battery life is so good it takes away any notion of battery anxiety!

Buy this phone if you want a truely useful diary and a portable device that you can really enjoy watching TV/Films on, surfing the web & awesome mobile gaming.

I have only one gripe...and it's not with Samsung. Jelly Bean no longer supports Flash...which was a big reason I chose my S2 over an iphone 4! C'mon Android, get back into bed with flash!

Posted:A year ago

#8

Login or register to post

Take part in the GamesIndustry community

Register now