Sections

Demise of single-player games overstated, says Dishonored dev

Harvey Smith thinks concerns are a side effect of market expansion, hopes studios specialize more due to higher dev costs

There's been a lot of doom and gloom surrounding single-player games this generation. They're dying. They're a gimmick. They're harder to make money with. Consumers simply don't want them. At the same time, the single-player The Elder Scrolls: Skyrim dominated the awards season last year, and the similarly solo title Dishonored just won the Game of the Year award at last week's BAFTAs. (Interestingly, both games were published by Bethesda.)

Speaking with GamesIndustry International after the BAFTA win, Arkane Studios' Harvey Smith said he's heard the critiques about single-player games, but hasn't put too much stock in them.

"What people say each cycle is, 'Fill-in-the-blank is the new thing.' And if you're old enough, you remember when it was live-action video games," Smith said. "At another point it was MMOs. At another it was social games. At another it was multiplayer shooters. And none of those things are bad; they're all great. But what the reality seems to be is we keep adding types of games and finding new player groups for those. The market seems to be expanding."

"What the reality seems to be is we keep adding types of games and finding new player groups for those. The market seems to be expanding."

Harvey Smith

He pointed to the real-time strategy genre, which is generally considered moribund, but spawned the thriving DOTA phenomenon.

"It seems like our attention focuses on the new thing, but in reality, there are still plenty of people that like a particular kind of game," Smith said. "Every time someone announces the death of the single-player game, something like The Sims or BioShock Infinite comes along and does different things well. So far we haven't capped out. It's not like DOTA fans are buying DOTA and not playing Skyrim, or buying Dishonored and therefore not buying Madden. I think there's a bunch of different audience types and we haven't even hit the limit yet."

That doesn't mean every genre will stay the same. Smith noted that games used to be played a quarter at a time, and business models aren't about to stop evolving. Right now, he said every friend he has in the industry is grappling with how to make free-to-play games that aren't exploitative, even the ones that aren't actually working on free-to-play games.

"People will find designs that players love in that area," Smith said. "And I have faith players will let people know where they're willing to go and where they're not willing to go."

Smith also talked about player feedback on Dishonored, and whether he's heard calls for a multiplayer version of the title.

1

Smith has heard some clamoring for Dishonored multiplayer, but much more gratitude for the single-player focus.

"I hear everything," Smith said. I get tweets back to back that are, 'Oh my God I never saw that twist coming,' and 'Oh my God I saw that twist a mile away.' They're, 'Oh my God I love how blink worked' and 'Oh my God I hate how blink worked.' You just have to look at the bulk."

While Smith acknowledged hearing people ask for multiplayer, he said he'd heard people thank the team for making the single-player game the way they made it much more frequently.

"I hope there's some specialization happening and people are going to have to do one thing well or three things well instead of trying to do the same 12 things everyone else is doing."

Harvey Smith

Beyond having the successful models of games like Skyrim and Dishonored to follow, other developers could be also be encouraged to make single-player only games by the realities of business.

"God, I kinda hope so," Smith said when asked if the rising cost of development might force studios to specialize instead of attempting to be all things to all gamers. "I do know the days when some other publisher I won't name but was less happy with would be pushing a Flags mode on us or something like that. And we were like, we're doing two original things over here and we'd really like to double down on those because then players could tell us whether they thought that was cool or not. But we don't think they're going to be jazzed about, 'Oh and by the way we also added Flags.'

"So I hope people are specializing and going deeper on given mechanics. And I actually hope it gets to the point where there are so many people competing--indie developers or commercial developers--and they're so good at this one thing they do that in order to win, you have to differentiate. You have to do something well that the other guy's not doing. That'd be nice, right? Instead of a handful of games that all try to do the same thing, I hope there's some specialization happening and people are going to have to do one thing well or three things well instead of trying to do the same 12 things everyone else is doing."

Despite the BAFTA win, Smith and Arkane are not resting on their laurels. The next Dishonored add-on, The Knife of Dunwall, releases April 16. A third and final add-on, The Brigmore Witches, has not yet been dated.

Related stories

Arkane working on Prey 2 reboot - report

Arkane's Austin studio developing "spiritual successor to System Shock 2"

By Matthew Handrahan

Dishonored director: These kinds of games have always been hard to sell

Raphael Colantonio on the success of Arkane's first title

By Rachel Weber

Latest comments (10)

Dave Herod Senior Programmer, Codemasters3 years ago
If you make a good game, it'll do well, basically. As Dishonored shows.
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Lewis Brown Snr Sourcer/Recruiter, Electronic Arts3 years ago
Some of my fav games off all time are single player, Fallout 3 being the one that strings to mind. Its not dead and actually I think there is currently a gap in the market for more pure single player games again, time will tell.
2Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Adam Jordan Community Management/Moderation 3 years ago
There will always be a market for single player games just like there will always be a market for competitive multi-player games.

If we look at the VHS video tape and DVD, people claimed that DVD would eliminate VHS altogether, sure it made it obsolete but there are still people out there that buy videos and search the globe for Video players and combi-players.

Also look at the very gaming industry itself. Not only do people keep retro consoles around, they still play them or are prepared to buy a retro game "remastered" or made available upon a new platform.

Granted I will say my tastes for gaming has changed from say 10 years ago. A decade ago I would have played titles like Elder Scrolls to the very bone. Morrowind and Skies of Arcadia, I didn't just play for hours but for years, heck Skies of Arcadia made me buy the Dreamcast multiple times over the course of the decade. Now I prefer more co-op titles, however I still play single player games, I even have a nice pile of SP games to run through...Dark Souls being one of them and although I have completed Dishonored once, I want to complete it again along with the story DLC coming out for it.

Overall there will always be a market as long as there is a demand for it.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Show all comments (10)
Paul Jace Merchandiser 3 years ago
The title of this story should have been: "Rumors of The Demise of Single-Player Games Have Been Greatly Exaggerated". That way it could have fulfilled two cliches at once.
At the same time, the single-player The Elder Scrolls: Skyrim dominated the awards season last year, and the similarly solo title Dishonored just won the Game of the Year award at last week's BAFTAs. (Interestingly, both games were published by Bethesda.)
And let us not forget that a certain downloadable single-player title called The Walking Dead also did pretty well when it came to awards last year and this year.
2Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Kevin Patterson musician 3 years ago
I always laughed when someone said that single player was dead/dying. Single player is the game equivalent of reading a book, and to really enjoy the story, you need to experience it alone or at least with full concentration. It's hard to be moved by a story in a multiplayer game or co-op mode, and there are many gamers such as myself that love and prefer story driven games.
Dishonored is a great game, Im looking forward to what they do next.
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Gordon Sinclair Managing Director, Replay Events3 years ago
There is nothing more disappointing than a good game with no true single player option.
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Sam Brown Programmer, Cool Games Ltd.3 years ago
I've always seen "No single player" as "We can't write decent game AI". :)
2Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Kingman Cheng Illustrator and Animator 3 years ago
Call me oldschool but for me it's still about single player and local multiplayer. :)
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Caleb Hale Journalist 3 years ago
The cumulative quality of Internet connections around the world aren't quite good enough for developers to build all games solely around multiplayer.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Brian Smith Artist 3 years ago
Multiplayer games are great but all but the few die stone dead eventually. At one end of the spectrum a multiplayer game can have next to no audience online in only a month or two. At the successful end they can last a couple of years. Boot these games up in a few years time and they'll be all but useless. Single player experiences give us games that continue to work, even if there isn't a crowd of others wanting to play as well. This alone gives them a huge USP.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply

Sign in to contribute

Need an account? Register now.