Sections

Seizing Destiny

A great launch for Bungie's latest will please Activision investors - but Sony is the real winner, with PS4 positioned to reap the rewards.

Whatever Bungie chose to do after winning back its freedom from Microsoft and downing tools on the Halo franchise, it was always going to be a big deal. Halo was more than just a successful game franchise; it was a game franchise that established an entirely new platform, turning Microsoft's Xbox into a real contender in the market. It was a franchise that made online gaming on consoles really work for the first time, driving the Xbox Live service which would serve as Microsoft's primary competitive advantage for a generation. To call the Master Chief "Microsoft's Mario" is a bit of a stretch; but he's about as close as any other present-day platform holder's characters have ever come to matching the iconic nature of Nintendo's headliner.

Halo isn't gone, of course, with 343 Studios hard at work on the next instalment in the franchise, but it was inevitable that all eyes would be upon the team that created Halo in the first place as their next title was readied for launch. Destiny is, indeed, a big deal. Just how big in financial terms is a tricky question; the supposed $500 million Activision has invested in the new IP is a piece of industry legend that's actually remarkably hard to unpick. It includes a marketing budget that's easily as big as the development budget, as you'd expect, and includes a significant amount of money for running server operations, but it's not clear how much of that money will have been spent by this week, launch week, and how much simply remains earmarked for future development, future expansions, future operations. It's a big figure that's handy for impressing upon would-be competitors the sheer clout of Activision's finances, but not so useful for those curious about the company's true investment in the project.

"Platform battles are neither won nor lost off the back of an Xbox-exclusive costume or some ads with PlayStation's logo in the corner."

The downside to Activision's decision to try to impress the world with the size of its investment is that many people questioned whether its performance could possibly live up to the expectations being set. $500 million is a lot of money to earn back; if you're relying solely on boxed sales of a single game, you'll need to sell around 20 million copies, possibly more, to make back that investment. It's a much more reasonable amount of money if it actually covers several years of life for the franchise, with expansions, sequels, DLC and whatever else providing additional revenue; still, it's a big number, and had Destiny stumbled out the gate, Activision's investors would have felt their blood run cold.

It didn't stumble. It's the most pre-ordered new IP in history and, assuming no dodginess in the figures announced thus far, sold somewhere between 5 and 8 million copies at launch (the rather broad swathe of possible figures reflecting the fact that we don't know how many of the more expensive versions of the game, with extra content, were sold). Those copies added up to a conveniently familiar figure; Destiny turned over $500 million in retail sales on day one. No need to mention the psychological importance of that figure to Activision, who had announced it in no time flat. The game is still a long way from making a return on its investment (many other companies will take a cut of that $500 million before any of it sees the inside of Activision's pockets) but for investors, a solid launch was the first vital test of the game.

Activision will be relieved, and happy, no doubt. But you know who'll be absolutely ecstatic? Sony. Destiny is a multiplatform game, with the Xbox One version reportedly stacking up very impressively alongside the PS4 version in spite of the power differential between the consoles. Nonetheless, it's Sony who will reap the benefits of Destiny; in part due to a clever alliance with Activision for the launch of the game and in part due to prevailing conditions in the industry. That Destiny, a game available for several consoles, should be the primary driver of PS4 sales through to Christmas, seems flatly strange; certainly not an outcome you'd expect from a simple marketing partnership and some relatively ordinary timed DLC on the platform. Yet that's exactly what's happening, and it's worth examining why.

Sony has said publicly that it's treating the launch of Destiny as though it were a first-party game, and has sealed up an advertising deal which means that the Xbox One version is significantly under-marketed compared to the PS4 version. Destiny features heavily in Sony's own platform marketing, and players on PlayStation are rewarded with a handful of extra items that won't unlock on Xbox until next year. Although the internal approach at Sony - treating a third-party multi-platform game as though it were a first-party launch - is an interesting and innovative way of dealing with the situation, the nuts and bolts of this deal aren't unusual. Lots of games last generation had exclusive DLC for one platform or the other; many of them were wrapped up in exclusive marketing deals with one platform or the other; some were even timed exclusives overall, as is the case with Microsoft's (slightly ill-judged, I feel) deal for the next Tomb Raider. In reality, none of those things made an enormous difference to the "console war." Somewhere in the bowels of Sony and Microsoft's marketing offices, no doubt, there is a big spreadsheet that guesstimates how many new consoles were sold off the back of deals like these, but it's not a big percentage. Platform battles are neither won nor lost off the back of an Xbox-exclusive costume or some ads with PlayStation's logo in the corner.

What's happening with Destiny right now is something quite different; Sony's marketing tie-up and DLC bonuses are giving it an extra nudge, but the real reason why Destiny is pushing PS4 is simply down to market momentum; deals struck by marketing teams, I fear, have little to do with the ultimate outcome. Destiny is exactly the kind of game, at exactly the kind of time in terms of establishing new console platforms, which builds on a winner's momentum and turns it into a landslide. That's precisely what's happening now, and I expect that console sales figures over the coming weeks will confirm that hypothesis.

"Destiny is exactly the kind of game, at exactly the kind of time in terms of establishing new console platforms, which builds on a winner's momentum and turns it into a landslide."

Quite simply, PS4 has outsold Xbox One significantly thus far - and continues to enjoy stronger purchase intentions in retail surveys than its rival, so there's still more pent-up demand for Sony's new console than Microsoft's. Along comes Destiny; a game which is absolutely best played with your friends. Indeed, there's little point to playing Destiny unless you're going to have a few friends to play it with; personally, I enjoyed the beta but haven't bought the full game, since I live 8 time zones away from most friends who are likely to play and therefore don't think I'll get much value from it. Thus, if you're thinking about getting a new console in order to hop on board with what seems to be the online gaming juggernaut of the year, your choice will naturally tend to whatever your friends have already bought. More people have bought PS4s than Xbox Ones at this point; thus, with those existing owners as a nucleus, more people will be driven to buy PS4s, in order to play friends who are existing owners.

Destiny isn't unique in this proposition; it happened quite clearly in the last console generation, too. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare was the online game which most significantly pushed people to buy the console that friends already owned; it came a little later in the console generation than Destiny, but still marked a tipping point at which Microsoft's early advantage over the PS3 became self-sustaining and would not be overturned for several years. People who would otherwise have been more inclined towards the well-known PlayStation brand purchased Xbox 360s in order to play Modern Warfare with their friends online; having set up friends lists and earned achievements on Xbox Live, they then had a sense of inertia which kept them attached to Microsoft's console until the end of the generation. Many commentators said this happened because Xbox Live was simply a better online experience than PSN during that era; this was absolutely true, of course, but it wasn't the real deciding factor. A big online game favours the dominant party in the console battle and extends their lead; had PS3 been in the lead back then, players would have bought PS3s so they could play Modern Warfare with their friends, regardless of how good or bad PSN was.

That's why, while it's sensible for Sony to throw its weight behind Destiny - after all, when you have an advantage, you press it to the fullest - this is a strategy which simply wouldn't matter if PS4 wasn't already in the lead. Had Microsoft secured tons of advertising and extra DLC with Destiny, it would barely have made a dent in sales; people would still buy the PS4 version because they're vastly more likely to have PS4-owning friends to play with. Sony will be able to claim a win for their Destiny strategy when the sales figures come marching in over the coming weeks and months, but in truth, the win was already in the bag the second it became clear that Destiny would going to be a huge multiplayer game. For Microsoft, meanwhile, the bitter irony is that one of the biggest games yet for its new console is actually going to make it even harder to claw back any market share from PS4 by the end of the year.

Related stories

Number of Xbox One X enhanced games rises to over 130

L.A. Noire enters steadily growing catalogue as pre-orders re-open

By Haydn Taylor

Phil Spencer joins Microsoft senior leadership team

Xbox head and executive VP of gaming gets nod to join 16-member panel of company's key voices

By Brendan Sinclair

Latest comments (14)

Steve Wetz Reviewer/Assistant Editor, Gamer's Glance3 years ago
The sentiments in the article are probably more true for Destiny 2 than Destiny.

It is fairly certain that the Xbox 360 version will be the highest selling version of this game, if for no other reason than it is the most adopted console currently supported. Microsoft will be just fine for now. As for whether Microsoft should have chosen not to send Bungie truckloads of money in exchange for their loyalty a la Square Enix...
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Andrew Ihegbu Studying Bsc Commercial Music, University of Westminster3 years ago
I have always felt that post CoD Activision was a different beast, and I am still not entirely sure that I am happy with their price/value relationships. They always feel too perfect, like there's just enough content to convince me to buy, but I am not happy one bit about it because I know if it was any other franchise I would not and thus I feel a little fleeced.

I love Bungie, and Halo, and Marathon and thus I know I will like Destiny. But when it comes in the post tomorrow, I am not sure I will feel the same after 12 hrs simply because I will probably have gone through all the content, and buyers remorse will kick in.
2Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Pete Thompson Editor 3 years ago
I purchased Destiny on both XO & X360 and I'm thoroughly enjoying it on both.Although It's not as story driven or as engaging as I was hoping it would be having played all of the Halo series. I was going to pick up a PS4 copy aswell, didn't bother in the end, I thought that not allowing a multi-platform game to be advertised on both of the platforms that it's being released on was misleading and quite a low move by Sony,.but then I got off the Sony hype train shortly after taking delivery of my PS4 on launch day.
Many commentators said this happened because Xbox Live was simply a better online experience than PSN during that era;
Not only during that era, It still is today simply a better online experience.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Show all comments (14)
Neil Young Programmer, Rebellion Developments3 years ago
It is fairly certain that the Xbox 360 version will be the highest selling version of this game, if for no other reason than it is the most adopted console currently supported
I wouldn't be so sure - according to vgchartz, the 360 came in forth for sales of watchdogs (ps4 came first).

Also, destiny is available on the PS3 as well, which has if anything a larger install base than the 360.
3Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Jay Moore Founder, The Alacrity Group3 years ago
This is totally anecdotal, but from the massive carpet bombing TV ad buy Sony had my wife convinced Destiny was an exclusive on PS4. And it was the catalyst that got my 20 something nephews to purchase it bundled with a PS4 to play it (as all their friends had it on PS4) and they are PC gamers by and large buying mostly on Steam and playing LoL.
2Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Klaus Preisinger Freelance Writing 3 years ago
Destiny is a perfect showcase of how the production value of the gameplay design does not match the production value of the visuals on the new consoles. For some of the most prominent issues, such as co-op scaling between friends, there exist perfect solutions already, which seem to have been ignored. One wouldn't forget to put textures in a game, but one can omit proper scaling and match-making? Welcome to 2014.

As it stands, Destiny is far from becoming an unsuccessful game, but looking at the character transfer schemes between generations, I would not hold my breath, if I was Sony or Microsoft. Expectations there might not be met. Destiny is just a good game among other good games; not game of the year and not the personal Jesus of any platform holder.
2Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Jeff Kleist Writer, Marketing, Licensing 3 years ago
I've always felt Bungie, like Valve is highly highly overrated.

I believe, and this is again opinion, that the root of Halo's success has been that most people had not played an FOS since Doom, and so Halo was a. Revelation, and became a brand of choice, not because they were great games, but a "first love". I play them, like with Destiny because they're not bad, and my friends are playing them. I doubt I'll still own Destiny a month from now though I'll finish the campaign and have had my fun, as endless "events that are mostly different by he prizes they award are not appealing to me. .
2Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Nicholas Pantazis Senior Editor, VGChartz Ltd3 years ago
@ Pete Seriously? Cause Microsoft never does this... Oh wait https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TYBhyxWQk90
3Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Destiny could have done with a longer alpha
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Aleksi Ranta Category Management Project Manager 3 years ago
Destiny feels constantly on the verge of greatness but never really getting there. Very frustrating to play due to long load times, clumsy inventory management and so on. Borderlands im my opinion nailed this type of Loot whoring shooter genre and while Destiny has its production values very high, it just isnt accomplishing anything new really.
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Jan Almqvist Senior Level Artist, Ubisoft Quebec City3 years ago
Borderlands was overall a much better game with heaps of soul but I'm not giving up on Destiny just yet. I've had a few entertaining hours and hopefully it'll grow to something epic enough to match the pre-hype and marketing.
(Not sure I agree on the high production values though. I think doing four platforms hurt them and I don't think it looks that good to be honest. Next year's games will blow it away completely and that might be a tricky position to be in if you want it to stay relevant for the reminder of the generation.)
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Klaus Preisinger Freelance Writing 3 years ago
Compare the tone and mood both the Destiny game and its pre-launch campaign tried to set up. Then look at the live-action trailer. A guy fighting hundreds of monsters on the moon and yet putting away his automatic rifle to shoot with a pistol. Yes, only in an ad to a Bungie game would you laugh at this for being accurate. And the award for "silliest thing to do on the moon in a trailer" goes to....

Borderlands might be right, co-op team shooter are more like TV sitcoms than heavy dramas. Not that Destiny was a drama, it is just weird. Ghost thingy revives player who probably died in Russia during an alien attack centuries ago and fails to ask the most basic questions after being revived. At least the Master Chief evoked some imagery by means of his visuals and revival process when Bungie did this to him in the first Halo. Your Destiny character just having apparently been revived from skeleton state in a Russian ditch does not have that luxury and it only goes further into crazytown from there.

Destiny pulled it off to set up a mood, but it has yet to set up a plot and characters I care about. However, the game stakes its DLC on customers, such as me, doing that!
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
I reckon Destiny works when you play with mates...but solo, it will feel solo and desolate
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Elphège Kolingba Marketing Manager 3 years ago
Wait & see :)
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply

Sign in to contribute

Need an account? Register now.