The industry is still "developing games in a bubble"

FlavourWorks' Jack Attridge says Conan O'Brien's Clueless Gamer videos are proof of how inaccessible games have become

Video game developers have become too accustomed to serving the same audience, and do little to help newcomers learn even the most basic conventions to play them.

That's according to Jack Attridge, founder of FlavourWorks and former 22Cans designer, who discussed the origins of his upcoming interactive live action thriller Erica at Develop:Brighton 2019.

When trying to work out what FlavourWorks' first project would be, Attridge starting thinking "from the very foundations of what it takes for a video game to be made" -- which, for him, meant starting with the default interface for Unity. When you start a game project, you're presented with a 3D cube in a grey void.


Jack Attridge, FlavourWorks

"Usually when you're looking at this cube in a 3D room, you're like 'What do I do this cube?'" said Attridge. "Does it become a character? Is a human? Is a tank or a car? And you end up first exploring how this cube exists and moves around a 3D space.

"The result of that is 99% of games end up being about traversal, which is really weird because it means all our challenge, all our gameplay comes out of your exploration of a 3D environment. That's really funny because we don't really think about that in the real world. We don't think about how complicated it is to walk up to a door and open it -- that's second nature for us. So it's weird that this is the reason why so many of our games about running, jumping, shooting."

This made him think about how games are traditionally about external conflicts, but when you look at film, TV, books and theatre, they're generally about internal conflicts. If you don't focus on moving something around in a 3D space, you have to start thinking about finding new gameplay outside of traversal -- something FlavourWorks was keen to explore.

What really opened his eyes, however, was watching Conan O'Brien's Clueless Gamer segment. Attridge saw a video of the US TV host trying to play Resident Evil 6 and started to recognise how the industry "has been developing games in a bubble."

"We're all developing for the same audience," he said. "There's this weird thing where you almost need an education to play video games because there are loads of conventions we've built upon for 10, 20, 30 years. Nowadays, we don't even tutorialise people about how to use both sticks on the controller -- we just assume they're used to these conventions."

Without that education, O'Brien was "seeing all these really interesting things that we've taken for granted." In the clip, the presenter bumped repeatedly into another character without provoking any reaction and mocked the fact that the "cool guy with the gun [was] blocked by a small folding chair."

Attridge, and almost every other player, didn't have that issue with Resident Evil 6 but it showed the sort of thing we have become used to, both as developers and gamers. For developers, if they want to channel players down a certain path, they often place immovable obstacles like the aforementioned chairs to block other avenues.

"But someone else who's not used to those restrictions immediately finds it kind of weird."

"Nowadays, we don't even tutorialise people about how to use both sticks on the controller -- we just assume they're used to them"

Another example is games' use of doors, where some can be opened and access other areas, but others might be painted or locked to give the illusion of a world beyond the immediate area but are actually just part of the wall.

Attridge went on to use his mother as an example of the different motivations for playing games. He tried to get her to play Godus, the god sim he co-designed with Peter Molyneux. While the game tries to steer players to grow their population, Mrs. Attridge "didn't care about that goal."

"For her, she just wanted to have this nice quiet village by the sea. All of her emotional drives were at conflict with what the game wanted her to do."

Most players accept that a game will present you with challenges that it is expects them to solve, and they obey. But for someone who doesn't approach tasks like that, it can be a very different experience.

Another interesting point was the association some people make with CGI characters. Outside of games, the majority of CGI is reserved for family films -- you rarely see a Hollywood CGI film telling mature, adult stories. But again, players are used to this look because "that's the aesthetic of video games."

This led to insight as to why FlavourWorks has opted for live action when developing its debut title.

"We spend millions of dollars trying to render something close to the human face, and sometimes they look absolutely gorgeous," said Attridge. "But with film, all you do is point the camera at an actor and you get all this nuance for free. We just can't replicate that."

With Erica, FlavourWorks' solution to overcoming that need for an education in games conventions was to use "intuitive input and film language." The game is structured much like a film, albeit one where the audience can interact with what's happening on the screen throughout. And that interaction uses the studio's proprietary touch-based technology, meaning players can control the game with either the PS4 touchpad or, more likely, a smartphone (Erica is part of Sony's PlayLink series).

Later in the talk, Attridge demonstrated the opening for Erica: a Zippo lighter appears on the screen. With no instructions, players soon work out they can draw their finger across the phone to flip the lid in real time, moving it back and forth as they see fit, before flicking down the mechanism that lights it. The flame appears, and the game begins.

Following his mother's experience with Godus, Attridge says the game will geared more towards "emotional drive than skill," relying on engaging the player with a compelling character and story that allows them to choose how they want to progress. is a media partner for Develop:Brighton 2019 and attended with the assistance of the organisers.

More stories

Little Hellions nearing deliverance after seven years

Jace Boechler shares two key decisions that helped bring their passive-aggressive fighter to the brink of release

By Brendan Sinclair

"We want to be proud of Battlefield 2042"

The new head of EA DICE discusses the studio's transformation into a live service business

By Christopher Dring

Latest comments (6)

Andrew Jakobs Lead Programmer 2 years ago
The same BS just to get noticed hoping it will generate some traffic/news for his upcoming new game.. We've heard these things so many times before, it's nothing new, and he also won't change it with his new game..
2Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Stephane V IT 2 years ago
Well there was a time where tutorials were very popular. Then after that time, it became very insulting so developers removed them. Then they came back with a 10-15 minute run in the first part of a game and most of the time this is where it is right now. So even after a tutorial if you still don't know how to play the game properly...maybe you shouldn't and someone so guide you like a shoulder guide.
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Alex Barnfield Lead Engineer, 17-BIT2 years ago
Not every game can be accessible to new gamers; and it's not every single games responsibility to be a stepping on point. It'd be a really interesting thing for platform holders to tackle though.

Resident Evil 6 is not a fair example as it was criticized for these things at the time (and is the worst regarded of the main range for this reason).

I do think the industry is living in a bubble, and that's why indie has gotten so big. You don't see indie films making headlines, but now if you want some variety in games you have to step into indie because decades of experience have said that certain things don't sell. And unlike the film industry the games industry hasn't learned to view tastes as something which cycle rather than unaltering absolutes.

Edited 1 times. Last edit by Alex Barnfield on 15th July 2019 12:42pm

0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Show all comments (6)
James Coote Independent Game Developer 2 years ago
When is "nice quiet village by the sea" simulator coming out?

I feel like we're learning the wrong lessons. Tutorials and controls are solveable. The problem is there's only a narrow range of subjects devs seem interested in covering.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Same as any new hobby. If I would start, say motocross for example, I would have no idea about the rules, equipment, fixing the bike etc. But that doesn’t mean motocross would be in a bubble. So, completely misplaced claim.
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
”all our gameplay comes out of your exploration of a 3D environment. ”

I’m sorry, what? Maybe he had hard time coming up with a subject for his session. Because he does not seem to know what he is talking about at all.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply

Sign in to contribute

Need an account? Register now.