What yesterday's EU court ruling means for the games industry

Companies are advised to start acting quickly or face legal trouble once ruling implemented

Game companies should take appropriate action now to avoid legal trouble after yesterday's European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruling.

That's according to Sebastian Schwiddessen and Dr. Matthias Koehler from international law firm Baker McKenzie, which regularly advises companies from the video game and creative industries on media, IT and employment-related matters.

Yesterday the ECJ ruled that employers in Europe must set up a system to track the daily working hours of their staff. The decision is an effort to crack down on unrecorded overtime and properly enforce the EU Working Time Directive, which restricts employers from making staff work more than 48 hours a week, and grants at least 11 consecutive hours of rest every 24 hours.

With the seemingly unending problem of crunch in the games industry, this ruling could theoretically help protect developers from exploitative management practices.

Crunch in the industry is both a cultural and legal issue. While the EU Working Time Directive technically protects developers from being overworked, there are currently no means of enforcing it.

Employees are able to opt-out of the directive, but it has to be done so voluntarily and in writing. Furthermore, employees are free to opt back in without restriction, and are able to cancel their opt-out agreement even if it was part of their employment contract. However, stories from studios that battle crunch indicate it's often a problem with culture, the unspoken social contract, and woeful management.

With no means of enforcing the EU Working Time Directive, developers who are overworked often don't formerly opt-out; they just work the extra hours. However, with the working days being tracked and reported, it becomes harder to simply put pressure on people to waive their rights. Formalising the process is intended to take it out of the shadows, and discourage the practice of crunch because everyone would have to agree first in writing, or the company would find itself in severe legal trouble.

"Financially, the ruling may result in an increased enforcement of overtime pay," Schwiddessen told "At present, claims for compensation of overtime work are often rejected due to the fact that employees bear the burden of proof that overtime work has in fact been performed. With the introduction of a recording obligation, such proof would no longer be a problem."

While there is no set timeline for the EU Member States to follow, the German Secretary for Labour is expected to enforce the ruling for Germany on January 1, 2020. Pressure from labour unions across the EU could also ensure a "swift implementation of the new rules."

"Thus, the new ruling makes the ongoing efforts of unionisation in the video gaming industry that we are currently seeing in various countries such as the UK and Germany even more relevant for gaming companies," he added.

With the advent of more flexible working conditions in the digital age, certain restrictions such as the 11 hours of consecutive rest don't necessarily meet the needs of modern working people. According to Schwiddessen and Koehler, the ruling provides an opportunity for EU Member States to "modernise their often outdated working time acts."

"Member States will be given discretion as to the form of an objective, reliable and accessible system enabling the recording of the duration of time worked each day by each worker," said Koehler. "The pertaining national provisions shall in particular take account of the specific characteristics of a given sector of activity, or the specific characteristics of a given enterprise, including its size."

However, critics of the ruling have raised concern of the heavy administrative burden placed on employers to document working hours. Others have suggested that it unjustifiably interferes with employees' right to privacy when working from home, but both complaints were rejected by the ECJ.

For the record: This article previously stated that prison sentences could be handed out for failure to adhere to the ruling after it is implemented. While this is theoretically possible, it's currently unlikely according to experts.

More stories

CEO says Embracer "will not change in any way" after Saudi Arabia $1bn investment

Lars Wingefors explains the rationale for accepting investment from Savvy Gaming Group

By James Batchelor

EA won't make public statement on abortion rights

Publisher says it will only speak out when there's a "consistent perspective" shared by all staff

By James Batchelor

Latest comments (3)

Ian Griffiths Product Owner, Hutch3 years ago
The EU endlessly finding new ways to make business harder for new entrants! I wonder how long it is before running a business is so much red tape that it's almost impossible to get any actual work
done. Does this mean the end of working from home? How is the company to know that I stopped working when I said I did?

I don't want to punch in and out of work. This endless nonsense will see the end of the EU as its onerous and draconian demands become too much for citizens and business to bear.
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Rogério Marques Game designer 3 years ago
@Ian Griffiths: When I work from home, just like I do when in office, I log my work time in an issue tracking software (in our case Jira). I think that satisfies the "if overtime happens there is proof of it".

It is even a management malpractice imho to have a software project happening and not having implemented this practice, because it has other advantages besides providing proof of overtime. It also makes the project much more manageable.
4Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Ian Griffiths Product Owner, Hutch3 years ago
@Rogério Marques: You make think that satisfies proof of overtime but that doesn't mean the courts will. Given this ruling occurred in the first place it doesn't sound like it comes from people who trust the individual.

I completely disagree with you on software project tracking. I don't feel the need to track every minute of my team's work, I prefer to work based on trust and empowerment; hence why I'm part of one of the best places to work in the games industry.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply

Sign in to contribute

Need an account? Register now.