Find out how to kick start your games industry career

Get Your Free Ticket Today

Valve under fire for 'greedy' Artifact monetisation system

Developer introducing new features during the game's beta to alleviate some concerns

Valve is facing a backlash against the mechanics of its latest release Artifact, a card-collecting game based on the popular Dota series.

PC Gamer quotes multiple Reddit threads and Twitter users where players are complaining about the monetisation system seen in the Artifact beta.

The game is sold for $20 with a a set of starter cards, but the only way to collect more is to buy them with real money. Players can either buy booster packs for $2 or buy and sell individual cards to each other for various prices, with Valve taking a share of each sale.

The only way to win new cards in-game is by playing special modes and events, but these require tickets to enter, which must also be purchased with real-world money.

There is no ability to trade cards at the moment, meaning there is no way to clear duplicates from your collection. spoke to the team behind Artifact earlier this year, who claimed the idea was to model physical trading card games, where you need to buy or barter for every card you own.

"It's not pay to win... it's pay to participate," lead designer Richard Garfield told us.

But users complaining about the system have described it as "pay for everything you do", with others saying they're "saddened by the greed Valve is showing" and slamming these paywalls as a "huge fucking mistake."

Valve has since posted an announcement about planned changes for the game, which address these concerns. The company said it has received "an overwhelming amount of feedback."

Going forward, players will be able practice certain modes without spending event tickets, and that unwanted cards can be recycled into event tickets. The former is in effect immediately, while the latter will be introduced "over the next week and a half."

Find out how to kick start your games industry career

Get Your Free Ticket Today

More stories

Valve releases game compatibility details for Steam Deck

Company says the categorization of games with portable device will be an ongoing evaluation process

By Jeffrey Rousseau

Valve files for dismissal of Wolfire Games' antitrust lawsuit

Steam's parent company filed a motion to dismiss, saying its practices do not harm competition

By Marie Dealessandri

Latest comments (2)

Alfonso Sexto Lead Tester, Ubisoft Germany2 years ago
"It's not pay to win... it's pay to participate,"

Didn't the users did that already with those initial $20?
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Klaus Preisinger Freelance Writing 2 years ago
No, the initial $20 are pay to start the executable.
The microtransactions are then pay to participate.
Not to be confused with the streaming ticket which is pay per view.
Not to be confused with expansion packs which are pay to mix it up some more.
Not to be confused also with the money you spend buying cards to build a deck according to optimized meta-strategies which is pay2win indeed.

and since Valve frowns on py2win, they will change that meta with monthly updates to make things more balanced. If that somehow, by accident, serendipitously causes a new meta to emerge for which you would need to buy new cards to keep winning quickly, then you can either trust in Valve and wait for another balance update, or pay2win some more in the meantime, consumer choice is important, after all.

You see Alfonso, you are in the best hands here.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply

Sign in to contribute

Need an account? Register now.