Sections

Why Peter Moore once told Sega's Yuji Naka to "f**k off"

The outgoing EA exec looks back on his Sega days and how the Japanese company "didn't see the stormclouds" in the industry

In late February, right in the middle of the Game Developers Conference, it was revealed that EA's chief competition officer, Peter Moore, would be leaving the publisher to take a dream job as the CEO of the Liverpool Football Club this June. After two decades in the games business, having overseen the launches of the DreamCast, the Xbox 360 and contributing to the rebuilding of EA's brand, the veteran talked candidly with Glixel about a number of his experiences in the industry over the years.

Perhaps the most fascinating insight came from Moore's discussion on Sega and how the once great gaming company had failed to evolve with a quickly changing games ecosystem. After Sega had already ceased DreamCast production and transitioned into a third-party software firm, Moore said he had a lot of trouble attempting to get Sega in Japan to understand the shifts that were taking place in the global business.

"We started to go up there a lot and build a relationship, and I was going back and forth to Japan and I was just so angry with Sega that they didn't see the stormclouds of what was happening in the industry," he commented. "Games like GTA 3 were changing the vibe of the content. That was, to me, this inflection point. Once the tech started to get more powerful, the creative elements that would come over from Hollywood and from television all of a sudden - that was what gave us Rockstar, and what the Houser brothers, to their credit, did for games. I mean, you look back on the history of this industry, you can point to these moments and say, 'That's when everything started to change.'"

Moore explained that to prove his point, Sega had conducted focus groups with players in America to get a sense of how they view different gaming brands, including Sega, of course. "I needed to prove to the Japanese that our brand was starting just to fade away. And so we asked the focus group, a bunch of 18-, 19-year-olds, a classic question, 'If a video game publisher was a relative or a friend, who would they be?' Ah, EA. Arrogant quarterback, 6'5", walks in, gets the girl, nobody likes him, blah blah blah, but, you know, fills the room with his big personality, all that. I can hear it now.

"Rockstar. Ah - that's your drunken uncle that shows up from Vegas once a month with a hooker on his arm and looking for money and then he's gone again. He comes in and he's the life of the party for a little while, and then he disappears for a long time. Sega. Yeah, that's your grandad. Used to be cool, but even he can't remember why anymore."

When Moore brought a video of the focus group to present to his Japanese colleagues, they refused to believe the validity of what the American consumers had been saying. That's when things got especially rough with Sonic creator Yuji Naka.

"I said, 'We need to be incredibly aware of the challenges we face as a brand at Sega,' you know, and so I play the video. Yuji Naka, Naka-san, maker of Sonic, is in the room. Now, he and I have a love/hate relationship on a good day. And we show him this, and it's subtitled in Japanese, and when it comes to that piece he just [slams his hand on the table], 'This is ridiculous. You have made them say this. Sega is the great brand, nobody would ever say this, you have falsified!' He just gets in my face. So I said to the translator, 'Tell him to fuck off.' And the poor guy looks at me and says, 'There's no expression in Japanese.' I said, 'I know there is.' And that was it. That was the last time I ever set foot in there," Moore explains.

"I rarely get upset, but to be accused of doctoring a video, because there's none so blind as those who will not see, right? I loved Sega, still love Sega, but it was dominated by the developers to the extent where Sega as a company couldn't move if Nakagawa-san, Yu Suzuki, Iguchi weren't into it. The world was changing around them, and we were desperate. I said that we've got to get content that is mature. It's ironic to me that one of their best-selling games, subsequent to all of that, is now Yakuza."

Serendipitously, it wasn't long after that argument that Moore was approached by Robbie Bach and the Xbox team. Moore talked about how he loved being the "challenger brand" to take on Sony, and how he orchestrated the whole launch strategy, including information leaks about the Xbox 360. The toughest part for Microsoft, of course, was the infamous "Red Ring of Death" that plagued the hardware and could have permanently tarnished the Xbox brand. In fact, Moore asserts that if Microsoft boss Steve Ballmer didn't agree to take the financial hit to invest in a fix, it would have been game over - there would be no Xbox One or Scorpio.

"Thank God for Steve Ballmer, you know, not flinching when I told him, 'I think this is a $1.15 billion problem we've got on our hands.' He just said 'do it.' And, you know, if we hadn't have done that I don't think Xbox would be in existence today," he said bluntly. "Our product was failing, it was failing the players, and we needed to do something about it. There was a lot of overnight shipping going on there, and a lot boxes being fixed or replaced, but it solved the problem and salvaged the brand. Otherwise we'd have been done."

There's plenty more reminiscing in the full interview and it's worth your time to read it.

More stories

Head of Chinese publisher XD plans to leave the country

Huang Yimeng says he's relocating abroad primarily for family reasons, does not plan to change citizenship

By Brendan Sinclair

The coming recession will hit the industry hard | Opinion

It's a long time since the games business was called 'recession-proof' - and recent changes could have made it more vulnerable to economic downturns than ever before

By Rob Fahey

Latest comments (1)

Benjamin Solheim Sole Shareholder, ESPN5 years ago
Yet that single moment may have nearly destroyed the Japaneses culture. Japan did not need griefer 12 year olds trash talking over xbox voice chat they needed a positive example not a game like GTA that is about hookers and blow. You can see the current trend is to look at the games that came before that change with the anime series that are sold as video games, and classic jrpg that focused on the story being good before the game ever ships. In a sports game you don't have to figure out who wins because the story is good either way. Video games are about a good story figuring out what makes a good story is something that gets lost along the way in most games because the target audience is usually an after thought. When you write a TV show or Movie the first thing that goes down on paper is an idea. The first thing you use to refine it is who can it appeal to and how watered down is the idea when you try to broaden the appeal to too many cultures. Games like Mass Effect had a huge following in many cultures because EA narrowed down the story to just the story and built a cool story to follow even if it felt like it was on rails at times. An Indy Car race or NASCAR race you have fans of every type cheering their team on because they need to be able to stand in the stands and see how is winning in the driver's spot is fun but you can not really see how close people are to passing you.
The fans looking down can see just how close or how far. Because it is not them when their team losses there is always the next race, when their team wins they were there cheering them on.
Most video games are built by developers trying to make the story they want to play while some times forgetting who a video game story needs to center around. I watch this with games that start out really strong and slowing the player's characters fall out of the spot light in favor of a developers NPC and players stop playing the game because when people play video games they want to be in the spot light how ever they happen to be there. Games were the player ends up impacting the story with those NPC seem to do the best where the story follows a coherent path while letting the players feel important and part of the story. Those are the games that are slowing replacing the GTA of the industry.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply

Sign in to contribute

Need an account? Register now.