Silicon Knights denied appeal in Epic case

US Court of Appeals upholds original verdict, Silicon Knights must pay all damages, costs and destroy Unreal products

The United States Court of Appeals has blocked Silicon Knights' attempt to overturn the verdict in its long-running legal battle with Epic Games.

In a decision taken last week, the Court of Appeals upheld the the lower court's ruling that Silicon Knights pay Epic $4.5 million in damages - plus roughly the same amount in legal costs - and destroy all code and products created with the Unreal Engine.

While Silicon Knights' legal team put forward several arguments for the appeal, all were dismissed by the court. This will likely be the final development in a case that first surfaced in 2007, when Silicon Knights filed suit against Epic for its failure to supply functional tools and adequate support during its development of the Xbox 360 exclusive, Too Human.

Indeed, Silicon Knights' existence has been tumultuous ever since it started legal action, with the studio periodically shedding staff until it closed its offices and sold its assets in May last year. At this point, it isn't clear in what capacity the company still exists, though it seems certain that it is no longer actively developing new products.

Dennis Dyack, Silicon Knights' founder and vocal figurehead, started working with Precursor Games on a new project, Shadow of the Eternals, at around the same time that his former company closed its offices.

However, Precursor's efforts to raise funding for the game on Kickstarter stalled, and it is now on indefinite hiatus.

Thanks Gamasutra.

More stories

Epic Games to release Unreal editor for Fortnite later this year

CEO Tim Sweeney said "we're building an economy, & it will support creators actually building businesses around their work…"

By Jeffrey Rousseau

Epic Games & Apprenti announce new Unreal Engine apprenticeship initiatives

The gaming firm will also be offering access to its Unreal Authorized Training Center via CG Spectrum

By Jeffrey Rousseau

Latest comments (1)

Greg Wilcox Creator, Destroy All Fanboys! 8 years ago
Ugh. Destroying games is to me like destroying books. THIS part of the ruling should be scrapped out of the NEED to preserve some for of history. Erasing something it took maybe years to create whether it's a good game or not just seems wrong to me...
3Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply

Sign in to contribute

Need an account? Register now.