Close
Are you sure? Are you sure you want to report this comment? I understand, report it. Cancel

Molyneux: Fable 2 had "huge design flaws"

Thu 15 Jul 2010 12:44pm GMT / 8:44am EDT / 5:44am PDT
Games

Admits RPG was "terribly messy" in some respects, and talks up importance of drama

Lionhead Studios

In 1987 Peter Molyneux founded Bullfrog Productions, along with his then partner Les Edgar in Guildford,...

lionhead.com

Lionhead boss Peter Molyneux has claimed that his most recent game Fable 2 suffered some critical failings.

Speaking today at the Develop conference, he said "Let's be honest, it had some terribly messy things about it. We rushed at the end, where we had this terrible phase where we went from 'the world looks this beautiful with this many features' to being less beautiful and less features because we had so many bugs."

He claimed a build submitted to Microsoft for testing sported around 61,000 bugs, requiring the studio to downscale the game's feature set.

"To be honest with you there were also huge design flaws in Fable 2," he said. "There were game features that people just didn't use or only used once. A great example of that was getting married. It didn't mean anything, it didn't add to the game. It was just an excuse to have sex, to find out whether it was another hot coffee."

Molyneux also talked up the importance of drama in games, claiming it was something the industry was largely overlooking. "I don't think we have taken drama seriously enough." Lionhead had not treated the narrative in Fable 2 as "a real story," he said, but hopes to address that with Fable 3's "much more simple" story and "great cast."

After showing a list of 'dream' intentions behind the upcoming Fable 3, he also admitted "what this dream really means is we want to sell loads more units. It means more money for our lovely corporation Microsoft, and also we love success."

8 Comments

Joseph Marlow
Blogger http://gamesburp.com

22 0 0.0
God. Dammit Molyneux. I love that guy. I mean he can sound pretentious and be over-reaching in his ambition but this polarity is part of his charm. If you don't believe a word he says, he's great. What a guy.

Posted:4 years ago

#1

Jake Clayton

54 0 0.0
Hes like the mel gibson of the game world, he always says he's going to reform, and we all know he isn't but we still love him.

Posted:4 years ago

#2

Kingman Cheng
Illustrator and Animator

945 161 0.2
It's good to recognise faults and try to better yourself without making excuses.
Unlike Apples new iPhone, I still haven't gotten over the whole 'oh just hold it a different way' advice.

Posted:4 years ago

#3

Finlay Thewlis
Studying Game Design & Production Management

26 0 0.0
Peter Molyneux is a great guy but my one criticism is of his presentations of his games. When fable 2 was coming out he listed all the things you could do like 'work in a pub', 'get married' etc etc. Which is fine but the problem was with the way he said that, it lead consumers to believe that these mechanics were very in depth (at least I did anyway) but it turned out that working in a pub was it, there wasnt more to it than that. Putting very small design features at the front of your game's promotion push can be mis-leading or at least mis-read...

Posted:4 years ago

#4

Dale Broadbent
3D Artist

4 0 0.0
I hated working in the pub. I did everything I could to avoid having to do those stupid side jobs. The rest of the game was wonderful - downloadable content? Sign me up!! If they had released more content I would have bought it. Not sure why they stopped... hmmm.

That last quote from Molyneux is just disturbing. I mean we all know in the end all that matters is a.)Do people love your game? and (b.)Did it sell a ton of units? But to just come out and say it like that just seemed crass.

Posted:4 years ago

#5

Jack Loftus
Contributing Editor

95 0 0.0
Was one of the design flaws Peter Molyneux?

Posted:4 years ago

#6

Josef Brett
Animator

296 0 0.0
I loved Fable 2, ut it is sooooo buggy. I've been playing it again this week and I'd forgotten how glitchy it is. Still a good game though.

On a side note, do you think that PM's critique of Fable is an artist trying to grow and atone for his (games) faults, or just empty PR speak?

I like Mr Molyneux and always enjoy his comments, but I remember him doing this (about fable) when Fable 2 was coming out, so it just seems like it might be a savvy marketing ploy...

Posted:4 years ago

#7

Aleksi Ranta
Product Manager - Hardware

268 124 0.5
Its becoming all to frequent to bash the previous game in a series. Cliffy B saying GoW2 wasnt too good in his eyes, Bungie saying Halo 3 wasnt their best work, PM now saying something similar in respect to Fable 2. Is it too easy to build anticipation for the upcoming game by saying the previous one was bad? I personally think that builds the hype too much and is bound to disappoint.

Posted:4 years ago

#8

Login or register to post

Take part in the GamesIndustry community

Register now