HomeNewsFeaturesJobsEducationResourcesDirectory

Matt Martin 09:38 (BST)
31/07/2008

Matt Martin

"Game reviewers are lazy," says AIAS president

The president of the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences has said that he believes games journalist are lazy when it comes to reviewing games.

Joseph Olin, a former Eidos executive, said that reviewers don't spend enough time playing games, and that there are "a lot of game critics, but very little critical analysis".

"My pet peeve is that game reviewers are lazy," he told Shacknews.

"Not all, but in terms of the reviews [something like] 'This game isn't as good because let's compare it to that game over there and that game was great.' Who gives a, you know, bleep?"

"How can you review a game, how can you give a comment about a game like Grand Theft Auto IV, that has 40-plus hours or more of gameplay, if you've only spent 2 and a half to 3 hours playing it?"

"It would be like reviewing a movie but only seeing the opening, first reel. I don't think that's fair, or is it accurate," he said.

Olin has been at the AIAS since 2004, and previously worked at Tomb Raider publisher Eidos as vice president of marketing.

The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences counts multiple leading publishers and developers on its board of directors including Epic Games, Ubisoft, Microsoft, EA and Nintendo.

Comments

To view other users comments, you must be logged in to a GamesIndustry.biz Network account.


In Related News

Retail

Tecmo Koei asks Sony to "please cut the price" of PS3

Tecmo Koei asks Sony to "please cut the price" of PS3

CEO says price cut is needed to boost the PlayStation 3's market share

Retail

Valve: Steam can boost boxed sales

Valve: Steam can boost boxed sales

Free weekends on service increase retail sales, claims Lombardi; Left 4 Dead 2 pre-orders already double that of original

Hardware

Sony patents motion control using ordinary objects

Sony patents motion control using ordinary objects

Everyday items can be scanned for use in-game

Retail

Activision: DJ Hero is "tremendous value"

Activision: DJ Hero is "tremendous value"

Publisher believes £108 RRP for game and peripheral is fair for amount of content included

Business

Thomas walks away with $5m from Midway sale

Thomas walks away with $5m from Midway sale

Original $100,000 purchase pays off for private investor as all other legal disputes settled

Business

Namco Bandai secures Dragon Ball rights for 5 years

Namco Bandai secures Dragon Ball rights for 5 years

Deal begins in 2010, but publisher will also release three titles this year

Newsletter Signup

Sign up to the FREE GamesIndustry Newsletter and receive a comprehensive round-up of industry news and info.


GamesIndustry.biz is the world's most read and influential games industry website. But don't just take our word for it!

"GamesIndustry.biz has a good mix of relevant business stories, with informed editorial from a team of professionals that I have considerable respect for."

Mike Hayes

Latest announcements courtesy of GamesPress
GamesIndustry.biz is a proud supporter of GamesAid.
Editor
Matt Martin
Display Advertising
Richard Sturgess
Classified Job Postings
Scott MacKintosh

Find out more

Hosted by dx.net

GamesIndustry.biz is hosted by dx.net.