Close
Report Comment to a Moderator Our Moderators review all comments for abusive and offensive language, and ensure comments are from Verified Users only.
Please report a comment only if you feel it requires our urgent attention.
I understand, report it. Cancel

Can we please make sure that mobile VR won't suck?

By Joost van Dreunen

Can we please make sure that mobile VR won't suck?

Mon 14 Mar 2016 2:56pm GMT / 10:56am EDT / 7:56am PDT
MobileVirtual Reality

Mobile is the next, and arguably most important, frontier in the rollout of virtual reality, says SuperData's Joost van Dreunen

Given the widespread adoption of smartphones worldwide, mobile is going to be the platform on which most people are going to first experience virtual reality. Let that sink in for a moment. Despite the focus on the Oculus, which promises fantastic resolution and visual experiences, no one currently owns any devices yet. Pre-orders have started, but the industry has yet to find out what consumer adoption will look like. Meanwhile, there are 1.3 billion mobile gamers out there. The high-end devices are expensive, priced between $599 and $799, are more complicated to set up, and require a much more powerful PC rig to get the necessary frame rates to make the experience seamless.

Smartphones on the other hand require only a simple download to get a first glimpse at VR. Already Google has shipped 5 million units of its cardboard, which is cheap and universal in its use. And big brands like Coca-Cola and McDonald's are hip to the trend. When the fast food chain began selling its Happy Goggles, it was a clear sign that marketers are now well-aware of the sparkly promise of virtual reality and are leveraging its novelty to sell, among other things, soda pop and hamburgers.

The issue is that we, as a creative industry, have to deliver on the promise of virtual reality.

With a growing number of companies, ranging from investors to advertisers, fueling the VR fire, we can anticipate a market correction. Specifically, when the various mobile VR devices start to arrive and people begin to first experiment with its capabilities, it is likely that this may be somewhat disappointing.

Recently, Unity's CEO John Riccitiello pointed to the immanent disenchantment that is likely to follow the current hype cycle. As a veteran from the games industry, he is all too familiar with the difficulty of rhyming what people expect with what is possible, and issued a sober reminder that the first few years of VR may prove disappointing.

1

Rather than growing in a straight line, consumer adoption will initially be gradual because of the price point of high-end devices. Reviewers and writers in the VR space will at first be critical of the technology not (yet) meeting expectations. After a few years, VR will catch up to its initial promise, prices will become more mainstream and adoption will accelerate

Worse, history may even be repeating itself. Following a sudden boost of investment that hoped to satisfy a seemingly limitless appetite for interactive entertainment, the games industry collapsed under its own expectations in 1983. A slew of crappy devices and terrible content managed to evaporate consumers' willingness to spend, thereby decimating the market's value. What ultimately salvaged the industry was Nintendo's insistence on tightly curated quality content.

"The role of mobile game developers is changing, because they are now in the position to determine for a large number of people what their first virtual experience will be"

Fast-forward to mobile VR, we already observe many developers looking to quickly occupy their own corner in the market. The emergence of a new platform creates a powerful and rare opportunity for, especially smaller, dev studios to stake a claim. It was the release of the iPhone that allowed Rovio to become the poster child of mobile gaming success during its early days. What Rovio did well was to use the platform's features, produce something that stood out in quality, and make its game's mechanics transparent to the millions of people who had never considered themselves to be gamers, let alone on a smartphone.

The hardware manufacturers are also putting in their bids. Unfortunately, here, too, not everyone is equally successful. A recent reviewer of the LG 360 VR, designed exclusively for its G5 phone, found it to be "one of the shittiest virtual reality devices I've ever tried." It is experiences like these that may very well set the tone for a large number of consumers when they find they cannot reconcile what they thought mobile VR was going to be like and what it actually is.

The role of mobile game developers is changing, because they are now in the position to determine for a large number of people what their first virtual experience will be. It's an incredibly difficult problem because game design, like all design, is about dealing with limitations. But right now VR is at its most exciting and pregnant with possibility. We can let our creativity run free in an untouched hyperreal realm of awesome experiences and infinite commercial success. Designers, publishers and hardware manufacturers do not have to adhere to competitive market forces, industry patterns, rising marketing costs, discovery issues, distribution problems or franchise restrictions. At least, not quite yet. And because none of that exists right now, mobile VR is untainted by everything that makes developing great experiences so challenging.

So the question before us: what do we want people's first experience with mobile VR to be?

From GamesIndustry.biz Recommendations by Taboola

4 Comments

Eyal Teler Programmer

118 159 1.3
So far my experience with mobile VR is much better than with PC VR (that said, my only PC VR experience so far is the DK2). It's just a primitive diversion really, but it's fun as that, and my kids thought so too. You're not tethered so you can watch movies and VR experiences with relative comfort. There's no real need for high end graphics, there's an experience to be had with simple graphics. And if you already have a good phone, the cost of entry is very low, so even if it's just a short term gimmick people won't feel cheated if they buy into it and don't like it that much.

I'd totally play an endless runner that uses real world ducking, jumping, sidestepping and turning (all I'd need is a padded room :). I can think of other adaptations that would be fun. But I'm mostly hoping for a good movie experience to be created, because from what I've seen (which is unfortunately rather grainy with current tech) a 360 degree movie is a pretty exciting upgrade over normal movie watching.

Posted:4 months ago

#1

Kevin Patterson musician

199 111 0.6
I am not sure how well the goggles actually work, but I am intrigued at the LG VR Headset's design. Rather than a headset you stick your phone into, tethering it via a cable would make a better and easier experience. Rather than have every manufacturer with it's own headset, i would like to see a mobile headset VR standard that works on any phone that has the hardware for it.

Posted:4 months ago

#2

Craig Page El Presidente, Awesome Enterprises

501 341 0.7
I'm pretty sure VR games will suck on phones. Because their GPUs aren't powerful enough to run anything in VR except extremely low resolution games with blocky MineCraft art styles.

Posted:4 months ago

#3

Eyal Teler Programmer

118 159 1.3
Rather than have every manufacturer with it's own headset, i would like to see a mobile headset VR standard that works on any phone that has the hardware for it.
Most VR headsets fit most phones. That's the cardboard idea.
I'm pretty sure VR games will suck on phones. Because their GPUs aren't powerful enough to run anything in VR except extremely low resolution games with blocky MineCraft art styles.
Why would you think that low power GPU's would result in blocky graphics? I'm just wondering. Low poly, fewer effects certainly, but the blocky style is pretty new. PC games went through the low poly stage without coming up with that style at all. A high end mobile GPU will likely be able to run something like Tomb Raider Anniversary at a high enough resolution and frame rate for VR.

Posted:4 months ago

#4

Login or register to post

Take part in the GamesIndustry community

Register now