Sections

ESA butts heads with UN over online harassment report

[UPDATE] UN pulls report on cyber violence against women and girls, apologizes for errors and poor sourcing

Last month, the United Nations Broadband Commission for Digital Development released a 61-page report titled "Cyber Violence Against Women and Girls." The Entertainment Software Association took issue with two sentences in that report, and today released a statement harshly criticizing the report for perpetuating "hyperbolic, outlandish, and outdated notions of video games and gamers"

After pointing out depictions of violence against women are common across mainstream media of all kinds, the UN report says, "Recent research on how violent video games are turning children, mostly boys, into 'killing zombies' are also a part of mainstreaming violence. And while the presentation and analysis of this research is beyond the scope of this paper, the links to the core roots of the problem are very much in evidence and cannot be overlooked."

The citation attached to the "killing zombies" remark points to a 21st Century Science op-ed published in the fall of 2000 that leans heavily on quotes from Lyndon LaRouche and his wife Helga Zepp-LaRouche, who at the time had been decrying violent video game culture and "the Pokemon cult," which they saw as promoting Satanism.

"In quoting Lyndon LaRouche and his wife, Helga Zepp LaRouche, the UN's source material cites Zepp LaRouche's work, 'The Mark of the Beast: America's Children Are in Mortal Danger,' in which she mistakenly reports that children as young as two abuse digital entertainment," the ESA said. "Medical professionals specifically have declined repeatedly to pathologize video game use."

ESA president and CEO Michael Gallagher added, "This is an uninformed, misguided, and unfortunate report. If the overall issue was not so serious, it would be laughable that the UN is citing this work. It is willful ignorance to utilize such incredibly outlandish and outdated data. ESA strongly supports empowering women and minorities and creating an inclusive digital environment that welcomes all perspectives. However, the UN does this important issue a great disservice and undercuts its credibility by spreading ridiculous stereotypes and false opinions."

[UPDATE]: The UN Broadband Commission has pulled the report and replaced it with a note stating, "This report is currently in revision and will be re-posted as soon as all relevant inputs have been taken onboard." Speaking with Motherboard, a representative for the United Nations International Telecommunication Union apologized for errors in the original, chalking them up to the scramble to finish and release the report during a busy time for the UN.

"Really, the big problem was footnoting which was not up to standard and we very much regret that," the representative said. "That is being revised very thoroughly. We are adamant that we will have these [footnotes] all corrected."

Related stories

Games for the Many: how Labour plans to win elections with video games

Designer Rosa Carbó-Mascarell on using video games to make politics accessible

By Haydn Taylor

Making the industry's voice heard on Brexit

Exiting the EU is one of the biggest challenges the UK games sector has ever faced; the industry desperately needs its access to skilled staff to be protected

By Rob Fahey

Latest comments (7)

Brook Davidson Artist / 3D design 2 years ago
Well I am glad there is actually a company who stands up against for such ridiculous claims. Hopefully they do not get bombarded with a hate mob that changes their minds, as tends to happen pretty often these days.

If things where not constantly misconstrued, made up, and over blown ... I bet the feminist movement would be doing loads better.

Also, still not sure why we constantly focus on the female side of harassment. I can understand if it was a specific issue for females, but it isn't. Anyone who has a big presence on the internet gets harassment. So we should be focusing on it as a whole, all the while making sure we have a very strict definition of what harassment is. Disagreeing, and having a different opinion isn't harassment and I don't want to see it being labeled as such. Heck even calling someone a name isn't harassment unless it's done repeatedly by the same person following them around and causing trouble.
10Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Andrew Watson Tools Programmer 2 years ago
The UN report is hilariously bad. A large number of citations don't even work, and one of them is just a link to someone's C:/ drive. It's no wonder that a lot of people who were formerly supportive of this report are now trying to distance themselves from it.

Edited 1 times. Last edit by Andrew Watson on 7th October 2015 9:40pm

4Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Neil Young Programmer, Rebellion Developments2 years ago
Confused by the insistence the issue is with the endnote/footnotes, which in this case is simply the citation?
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Show all comments (7)
Andrew Watson Tools Programmer 2 years ago
@Neil
Confused by the insistence the issue is with the endnote/footnotes, which in this case is simply the citation?
If you don't have good sources then you might as well just make up whatever you want.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Paul Jace Merchandiser 2 years ago
"Really, the big problem was footnoting which was not up to standard and we very much regret that,"
That's either going to end up on a bumper sticker or as a disclaimer on all sites that post reports such as this.
3Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Alfonso Sexto Lead Tester, Ubisoft Germany2 years ago
violent video games are turning children, mostly boys, into 'killing zombies'
I would expect that kind of description from a tabloid or sensationalistic TV News channel, not from the UN.
0Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Andrew Watson Tools Programmer 2 years ago
How will they "fix" the footnoting? By cherrypicking sources that agree with them and ignoring those that don't? I'm very skeptical.
3Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply

Sign in to contribute

Need an account? Register now.