Sections

PlayStation Home: Sony's most successful failure

nDreams CEO Patrick O'Luanaigh says goodbye to the virtual world

It was August 13, 2007. I remember clearly sitting in the audience at the Edinburgh Interactive Festival. A calm and smart-sounding Sony manager called Pete Edward stepped up and gave a presentation about their plans for an ambitious new virtual world: PlayStation Home. It blew my mind. I remember instantly seeing the huge potential that a world like this could have. I spent the next few months persuading Sony to let us create something genuinely unique, and managed to convince both Edward and Phil Harrison (Sony's PlayStation Home champion).

Just over a year later, in December 2008, PlayStation Home opened its doors. A few months later, we successfully launched Xi, an ARG (alternate reality game) which mixed Home spaces, games, websites and live events around the world. A game like Xi could only have happened in a place like PlayStation Home.

"I think Home always suffered from the fact that its founding father Phil Harrison wasn't around to promote it, guide it"

Sadly, Home's champion, Harrison had departed Sony earlier in 2008. And whilst many people at Sony worked incredibly hard since then to make PlayStation Home successful, I think it always suffered from the fact that its founding father wasn't around to promote it, guide it and make sure it was championed at the highest levels.

Although initially hampered by a lack of content, PlayStation Home gradually built a passionate and dedicated following. Despite Sony's attempt to make it either an 'advertising platform for PS3' or a gaming platform in its own right, it soon became clear that it was neither. It was a social platform. Users didn't want to play games - they could do that on their PS3 anyway. They wanted to talk, share experiences, party and have fun. That was what made Home so unique. When the PSN returned after the famous 'hack' in 2011, it was PlayStation Home that came back bigger and stronger than any other part of the network. At its peak, Home had several million dedicated users, a large proportion of whom forged genuine, strong friendships that will endure beyond the platform itself.

1

PlayStation Home also proved to be a fascinating place for experiments. Home saw the first ever free-to-play console games, huge reward-based communities, gifting, paymium gaming and a host of other unique business models. UK developers like nDreams, Lockwood and Veemee owe their existence to PlayStation Home, and vied with each other to create the most interesting and successful content. People say that Home was a commercial failure. But we generated seven-figure revenues for several years from Home, and other studios did as well. Try telling us that it wasn't successful.

Just over six years later, in March 2015, PlayStation Home will be shutting its doors. My feeling is one of sadness. Not because Home is closing (the PS3 is entering its twilight years, and the timing makes sense), but because Sony doesn't appear to appreciate what an incredible experiment PlayStation Home was. Sure, there were many fundamental things wrong with the design of Home. But there was also so much that was right about it. Players loved to spend money on virtual items - the ARPUs were great. But above all, it was the passion - the loyalty generated by Home - that will be long remembered by anyone involved with the platform. The community loved Home. Some people met on Home, then married in real life. For several people it was a refuge from the real world - a place where they felt safe and secure.

"We generated seven-figure revenues for several years from Home"

I still believe that had Harrison stayed at Sony, things may have been very different. But regardless of how you feel about PlayStation Home, no-one can deny that it has been an incredible experiment. Edward and his talented Home team have learnt more about virtual worlds than almost anyone else on the planet. Will Sony make use of this knowledge? Only time will tell.

I remain totally convinced that some company, someday soon, is going to create a virtual world that grows larger than Facebook. And when they do, someone will look back at PlayStation Home and say, "They were that close..."

nDreams is now focused on the virtual reality space and The Assembly will be a launch title for PlayStation's Project Morpheus and the Oculus Rift. For the Samsung Gear VR they've created Perfect Beach, a relaxation game and action title Gunner.

Related stories

Adventures in Virtual Reality

Three developers discuss VR development for first-person adventure games

By Dan Pearson

nDreams tops up staff and funding ahead of VR's big year

Four new hires and 2 million investment will strengthen its position for the launch of The Assembly

By Matthew Handrahan

Latest comments (6)

I agree, someday something like this will be huge, our society is leaning that way. With the govt and media playing the fear card all the time as if "outside" is some scary place, society may well move to a more virtual public setting. Kinda ridiculous, but so is parents walking and driving kids to school each day, but they do it because they are conditioned to fear everything.
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
John Cook Senior Partner, Bad Management2 years ago
Lovely bit of insight Patrick.

As for this - "I remain totally convinced that some company, someday soon, is going to create a virtual world that grows larger than Facebook." - I am reminded of who unexpectedly bought Oculus recently :-)
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Pete Thompson Editor 2 years ago
At first I quite liked Home because it was different, but for the past few years I've not really been on there as it was, well a bit boring and full of adverts / micropayments..

Edited 1 times. Last edit by Pete Thompson on 1st October 2014 6:06pm

1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Show all comments (6)
Andrew Jakobs Lead Programmer 2 years ago
One of the problems I think was with Home, was the loading times. It should have been streaming levels.
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Andrew - totally agree. Loading times were definitely THE biggest technical issue. Ironically that's something that the PlayStation Now/Gaikai technology would pretty much eradicate in the future!
1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply
Carl Hudson Studying Computer Science, University of Adelaide2 years ago
I don't understand the word FAILURE in this article, it's never explained on what level that it failed. It was a highly profitable social experiment that gave Sony the biggest MMO of any console. As a casual gamer that just played multi-platform racers and used PlayTV, I used PS Home more than any other title on PS3, and generally used it daily.

I for one am glad that some of the Home devs are now kickstarting a new version of Home, called Neotopia, for PS4.. Should be interesting to see how they go without Sonys interference..

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1222510567/neotopia

Edited 1 times. Last edit by Carl Hudson on 3rd October 2014 5:23am

1Sign inorRegisterto rate and reply

Sign in to contribute

Need an account? Register now.