Close
Report Comment to a Moderator Our Moderators review all comments for abusive and offensive language, and ensure comments are from Verified Users only.
Please report a comment only if you feel it requires our urgent attention.
I understand, report it. Cancel

Critical Consensus: Google Nexus 7

Critical Consensus: Google Nexus 7

Wed 04 Jul 2012 2:20pm GMT / 10:20am EDT / 7:20am PDT
Hardware

Google and Asus have created the first essential Android tablet, and a superior product to the Kindle Fire

In terms of hardware sales, no news is generally bad news. If a company's latest phone, laptop, TV, console, handheld or tablet is flying off the shelves it won't be able to get exact figures out soon enough; if the device is a struggling, you're more likely to hear about percentage increases and stolen market share.

Now, it would be unwise to suggest that the Kindle Fire is struggling, but after a strong start last year, Amazon's goal of launching a credible alternative to the iPad has started to look somewhat hopeful. The tablet has no doubt created a nice new revenue stream for the retail giant, but reports that unit sales have been well below Amazon's expectations are not hard to find, and, tellingly, exact sales figures certainly are.

So, with the possible exception of Samsung's Galaxy line, the tablet market is still very much the iPad market. And as much as Apple's design expertise makes us go all weak at the knees, it seems both desirable and inevitable that another tablet should come along, wow the critics, and steel a little of Tim Cook's lunch. The Google Nexus 7 may or may not be that device, but based on the reviews so far, it has the best chance of any Android tablet released to date.

"For those who only want to surf the web, check e-mail, play games and update their social media feeds, the Nexus 7 might be an even better choice than an iPad"

Wired

Produced in conjunction with Asus, the Nexus 7 runs on a quad-core Tegra 3 CPU that clocks at 1.3 Ghz, with 1GB of RAM and a 12-core graphics chip. The display is a 7-inch 1280 x 800 backlit IPS LCD in scratch-resistant "Corning glass", with pixel density of 216ppi - for the record, that's more than the iPad 2 and an 11-inch MacBook Pro. It supports Wi-Fi, Bluetooth 4.0, near-field communication. It has a GPS chip, a gyroscope, an accelerometer and a 1.2 megapixel front-facing camera.

Granted, it has no in-built support for 3G or 4G connectivity, and on-board storage is limited to 8GB and 16GB models, but there's a good reason: the 8GB Google Nexus will retail for $199.99, and the 16GB model will set you back an extra $50.

"That's the same price as the Amazon Kindle Fire and Barnes & Noble's Nook Tablet at the same storage capacity," notes Wired.com in its glowing 9 out of 10 review, the same score it awarded to Apple's latest iPad. "If you want a bit more room to download HD movies, music, games and apps, you can get the 16GB version for $250. At these prices, the Nexus 7 is frankly a steal when you compare it to what else is out there at the same cost."

Significantly, Wired believes the Nexus 7 stacks up very well against other devices that cost a good deal more. Specifically built to run Android 4.1 ("Jellybean"), Google's tablet avoids the "unresponsiveness, slow animations and stuttering screens" of other 7-inch devices, running as quickly and smoothly as almost any tablet on the market. "It feels as fast as Asus' larger Transformer tablets, and it performs as smoothly as the iPad, even when playing high definition games such as ShadowGun or playing back HD movies," the review notes.

1

"While the Nexus 7 isn't a full-on iPad-killer, it far out-classes anything else offered in the 7-inch category, and most 10-inch tablets too... For those who only use their gadgets to surf the web, check e-mail, play games and update their social media feeds, the Nexus 7 might be an even better choice than an iPad, given how much easier it is to carry around."

Endgadget is similarly impressed by the Nexus 7's performance relative to its price, even claiming that Google could reasonably have sold it for "much more" than the $200 asking price. However, despite tight integration with Google's full suite of services (maps, docs, gmail, Chrome, etc) and the Google Play store, the range of content available to Nexus 7 users is considerably smaller than on Kindle Fire.

"It has a great screen, solid performance and a clean, clear, uncluttered version of Google's latest operating system, Jelly Bean. From a pure hardware standpoint it beats the Kindle in every way possible - except for content. Amazon's selection almost always trumps that of Google's, both in terms of variety and cost, but that's one wonderful problem to have, because almost all of that content is just as available on the Nexus 7 as it is on the Fire. The only major exception is Amazon Instant Video, and with Netflix, we can live with that."

"Believe it or not, the last time I was surprised by a product with those same qualities, it was called the iPad"

The Verge

According to The Verge, Android 4.1 Jellybean is as much of a lure as the hardware itself. Indeed, the reviewer goes so far as to call the OS, "one of the best products that Google has ever produced," and comfortably ahead of both iOS and Windows Phone. This is helped in no small part by how complete Google's service suite has become, allowing Jellybean to connect and modify its various products to create a fluid and harmonious tablet experience. However, the same can't be said of third-party apps.

"While Google's new OS and latest app initiatives are very, very good, Android on tablets still suffers from an incredible lack of developer support. Mainstream apps like Twitter have yet to be updated to an appropriate tablet-friendly design, while others...seem to be slightly optimised but not working 100 per cent correctly. Some apps simply aren't optimised for the tablet in any way... This is still a problem Google needs to tackle if it's going to truly combat competitors in the space."

With the Android 4.1 SDK now available to developers the situation will likely improve over time, and these problems don't diminish what Asus and Google has achieved. Indeed, with an overall score of 8.8 out of 10, the only tablet to score higher is the most recent iPad.

"Google's Nexus 7 isn't just an excellent tablet for $200. It's an excellent tablet, period. In fact, it's the first Android tablet that I can confidently recommend to buyers - and not just because it's got a low price tag (though that certainly helps). It's a well-designed, powerful, and useful product, with lots of bells and whistles that makes it feel like a device that should be more expensive than it is.

"Believe it or not, the last time I was surprised by a product with those same qualities, it was called the iPad."

11 Comments

Graham Simpson Tea boy, Collins Stewart

219 7 0.0
It's a just a flat chromebook. No one wants them either

Posted:2 years ago

#1

Antony Carter Senior Programmer, Epic Games

85 47 0.6
The price is just perfect, a few good reviews about performance and ill definitely be getting one instead of an iPad

Posted:2 years ago

#2

Rogier Voet Editor / Content Manager

71 31 0.4
I have thought lang and hard about which tablet to buy. The iPad is king in design and avalable apps but the price is to high and itunes is the worst piece of crappy Apple put together i like the freedom of Android so this tablet seems to fit my wishes the best

Posted:2 years ago

#3

Kieren Bloomfield Software Engineer, EA Sports

92 79 0.9
Still don't want or need a tablet. Apple created that market themselves, they can keep it.

Posted:2 years ago

#4

Nicholas Pantazis Senior Editor, VGChartz Ltd

1,020 1,467 1.4
I enjoy tablets. For many things they're significantly faster and more efficient than PCs. Specifically browsing, checking email, news, etc. and it does all of that portably. Furthermore, I'll say that the 7" form factor is vastly superior for most day-to-day tablet use than the 10" currently employed by Apple and most Android tablets. It's lighter, easier (and MUCH less awkward) to hold and manipulate, has a small enough keyboard to comfortably thumb type, and for reading books there's simply no contest. It's outright uncomfortable to read on an iPad, and a joy on a Kindle Fire or Nexus 7.

For me, even if it were priced the same as an iPad, this would be the better purchase. I know it doesn't have nearly as much game support or as many tablet native apps, but I find tablet gaming shallow and unsatisfying on even the best of iPad games aside from short time wasters (the best of which like Angry Birds, Cut the Rope, and Where's My Water are available everywhere). What I do LOVE using tablets for is movies, books, and music, and in that case the Nexus is unquestionably superior to any model of iPad. There will never be a 4:3 device that's better for watching movies, no matter how high you make the resolution.

Posted:2 years ago

#5

Alan Pierce Programmer, Digital Delight

63 19 0.3
The only thing a tablet does faster than a pc is boot.

Posted:2 years ago

#6

Fran Mulhern , Recruit3D

863 707 0.8
I really wish people would stop with the whole tablet/PC argument - it doesn't matter. Whatever works for you, well, works for you.

I think this looks awesome, have already ordered one. I like my iPad, but it's a little too big to use to read for a long time etc, so the Nexus 7 could fit the bill perfectly. Kindle, Netflix, a web browser - that's all I really need.

Posted:2 years ago

#7

Stephen Woollard Online Infrastructure Specialist, Electronic Arts

146 71 0.5
I bought my generic 7" Android tablet for one thing only - to watch TV while on the treadmill in the gym. Occasionally I use it for one or the other of my kids to watch TV if the TV and PC are both in use, or when we're on holiday.

I have to agree with Fran; if it does what you want, then great. I'm not a massive tablet fan (and I wouldn't buy anything from Apple on principal) but I wouldn't tell anyone not to get one. It seems like for what their marketed for (web, email, books, TV etc) then tablets are fine.

The one thing that puts me off this tablet is that from what I can see it doesn't have an SD slot, and I like to be able to swap content. My tablet has a micro SD slot and a full size USB slot, so I have different storage options for my shows and shows for the kids. If the Nexus could do the same I'd order one, but for now I'll stick to my cheapo model.

Oh, @Alan - my PC cold boots faster than any tablet - solid state drives ftw :-)

Posted:2 years ago

#8

Luke McCarthy Indie Game Developer

35 0 0.0
Not necessarily, a modern Windows 7 PC with an SSD can boot faster than some tablets (note: booting is not the same as waking from sleep!)

Posted:2 years ago

#9

Fran Mulhern , Recruit3D

863 707 0.8
Stephen, you're right on the SD card slot. But I never really download stuff on my ipad. Any shows I watch are streamed from Netflix, and Kindle books are minimal in terms of size. The hardware has won me over too, it'll be interesting to see how the Nexus 7 does when it ships.

Posted:2 years ago

#10

Stephen Richards Game Deisgner

68 28 0.4
An SD slot would be very nice but I can understand why it's absent. As with the ipad, an SD slot would undermine the possibility of selling higher storage models at extra profits. Still, $50 is nothing compared to the extra expense of higher storage iphones/ipads.

And to be fair, you should at least compare like with like when looking at tablets and PCs. That is, compare tablets to low-mid end laptops and netbooks rather than high end desktops. For the same price range, you're unlikely to find a laptop that's as responsive, as portable and has as long a battery life as a good value for money tablet like this one. Of course, you can still generally do more things with a PC than a tablet, so it's really a matter of preference.

Posted:2 years ago

#11

Login or register to post

Take part in the GamesIndustry community

Register now